StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders by Pearce and Holbrook - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders by Pearce and Holbrook " will begin with the statement that over the years, research has been conducted to establish the best practice(s) in the treatment of offenders in substance abuse…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders by Pearce and Holbrook"

Best Practices In Substance Abuse Treatment For Offenders. Name of Student Student Number Submission Date Word Count: 1,630 Over the years, research has been conducted to establish the best practice(s) in treatment of offenders in substance abuse. This paper will review Pearce & Holbrook (2002) paper on “Research findings and best practices in substance abuse treatment for offenders. The structure of the paper will follow: Purpose of the study, theories of drug abuse treatment used, research participants, methodology, i.e. data gathering procedures and respective model findings. It will also look at its contribution to the general topic, limitations and how they can be addressed in future research in addition to evaluation of the limitations and strengths of the research before finally concluding. This review uses terms that shall be referenced as they are used. The major findings of the paper concluded that there is no single effective programme that can be applied to the (AOD Alcohol and other drug involved offenders’ rehabilitation. Purpose of the study The purpose of this study was to summarize the findings and best practices in treatment of substance and drug abuse by offenders. Theories of drug abuse treatment There are two main theories of drug treatment used by the researchers that are either applied as single models or in combined form. The disease theory proposes drug abuse and addiction to be a primary illness chronic in nature and described in three parts: physical, spiritual and mental. It is based on teaching the addicts coping skills for the illness throughout life by abstaining from them. The second theory, Social learning theory by Albert Bandura, holds that drug addiction can be treated by teaching and reinforcing acceptable pro-social behavior. Offenders learn drug abuse from the social arena which is later reinforced by the benefits derived from it such as pleasure and euphoric feelings. Treatments based on this model include reducing the availability of substances through restricted access, interdiction, and treatment (Parks et al., 1999). Research participants The research participants in these researches were mainly (AOD offenders from correctional facilities: prison and jails in areas where the particular studies were carried out such as Texas, New York, New Jersey, Delaware and California. The population comprised both males and females of both high and low risk offences out of prison with varied duration from release date and in others in prison. Methodology The researches employed different tools and instruments in collecting data. Screening, assessment and individual treatment planning was used where individuals were screened and assessed before being placed in the programs. Screening is the initial activity that identifies offenders likely to be having AOD problems whereas assessment is a process that helps determine an individual’s problem with alcohol and other drugs and appropriate level of treatment (Pearce & Holbrook 2002). This is aimed at collecting information on the particular services to be offered for the offender to cope with the societal challenges. Screening instruments included: The drug use section of the addiction severity index, Alcohol Dependence scale, the simple screening instrument and the Texas Christian University Drug dependence screen. The assessment tools included Offender profile index used for establishing the best AOD treatment for the victim. The Addiction severity index is the widely used standardized field diagnostic tool. After diagnosing the problem, the individuals were referred for specific case management. There are various case management models – case management provided by the justice system, case management provided by the treatment system, case management provided by a separate entity from the treatment or justice systems, and case management provided by multidisciplinary groups in the criminal justice system for offender management (CSAT, 1995). The treatment programs used vary in modality, setting, intensity and duration of stay. The three programmatic models for substance abuse treatment for offenders used are the Minnesota model (12-step), therapeutic community, and cognitive behavior therapy (Bryant et al., 2000). The participants categorized as either treatment group, drop out group or control are then evaluated and compared to establish which model works best according to results basing on recidivism (re-arrest rate) indicated by findings as follows. Summary of findings Findings from these researches were different since no single program proved to be more effective than the other. Both the prison based and the community based models showed closely related margins of success on reduced recidivism rates based on number of subjects. Prison based treatment models In prison based treatment it was found that arrest rates for the treatment group reduced greatly in comparison to those out of the programme (Lipton 1996) report. Butzin et al. conducted a research in Delaware CREST outreach center, involving community prison inmates with substance abuse records in a six month community based therapy. The recidivism rates following an18 month release and subsequent follow up indicated 30% for CREST completers, 52% for CREST non-completers and 57% for the comparison group indicating the programs minimal success margin. Simpson & Knight (1997), research with Texas in prison TC (Therapeutic community) treatment model with Texas Christian University’s institute of behavior research involving a 12 month after prison release follow up indicated those who completed the TC aftercare had a lower recidivism rate of 18% compared to 29% for TC non completers and 33% for the untreated group. In subsequent evaluations done by Wexler between 1992 and 1997 of the Richard Donovan Correctional facility program on drug abuse program based in California and the Forever Free programme in California with the California institution for women indicate the same margin of success for these prison based programs. Community based treatment models Different community based interventions produced related results in rehabilitating the victims. TASC (Treatment alternative to street Crime) program indicated TASC participants remaining in treatment longer than non TASC participants which impacted positively in the outcomes (Hubbard 1988). Lightfoot(1988) report covering the 1993 Multiple Offender Alcoholism Program which incorporated an individual based cognitive treatment plan on behavior aimed at reducing alcohol related crimes indicated fewer cases of criminal activity on active participants (61% decrease). Positive social behavior was also recorded during participation. According to another research conducted by Taxman (1998) using the HIDTA project found that 12% of the offenders committed crimes again in the 9 month they were in the community. This was a lower margin compared to their crime history. Other subsequent research such Kennedy (1999) Breaking the cycle project from 1996 in Birmingham, Florida, Washington Tacoma and Oregon posted the same results showing achievement of the BTC program. Contribution of the research to the general topic Research on the best practices in rehabilitating offenders in drug abuse is very instrumental in solving life’s problems associated with drug dependence that lead to criminal behavior. Knowledge about the different models used by the researchers is essential in giving direction to more researches that will follow and it is through the small leaps of improvement in the research field that a more elaborate and effective models shall develop to address the issue once and for all. The police department and other correctional departments in criminology are bound to benefit from such researches since escalating crime rates are bound to reduce significantly. Consequently the community in general shall stand to benefit from the reduced criminal activity to uplift the living standards. Limitations of the studies Despite the success margins associated with these studies, a number of setbacks were present. The number of subjects used dropped significantly due to drop outs which affected the sample and consequently the validity and reliability of the research findings. Another limitation to the studies was lack of enough empirical data to draw comparison from on the specific programs used since they have been applied very few times to come up with comprehensive tracking on the programs. MacKenzie & Hickman (1998). There is no enough research on community-based outpatient programs without in-prison treatment to draw any conclusions. In addition, some specific case of prison based treatment models used, hindered the acquisition of reliable results considering that the assessment was being done while they are in prison, it is most likely that the prison community can influence them to act otherwise to compromise the program. Lastly, some studies do not follow up whenever a relapse occurs thus vital data from which inferences could be drawn is lost. Addressing limitations in future In future researches in this field, it is recommended that certain measures be put in place to deal with the limitations. Active support systems should play their part in retaining the participants in the research to minimize drop outs. Future research should be focused on outside prison based treatments to avoid prison environment influencing the subjects. A follow up on inmate’s activities following their release should be conducted to gather more information on the subject’s activities that can better explain their relapse in addressing it better. Relapse and recidivism are significantly lower if inmates continue with treatment in the community following release (Harrel, 2001). Comparing strengths and weaknesses The strengths outweigh the weaknesses of the researches. This is explained basing on the instruments and tools used in data collection. Screening instruments recommended by researchers for criminal justice populations include the Alcohol Dependence Scale and the Drug Use section of the Addiction Severity Index, the Texas Christian University Drug Dependence Screen, and the Simple Screening Instrument. They found these instruments to be superior (Bryant et al., 2000). The approved validity and reliability of these instrument and their previous results in comparison to the weaknesses which can be eliminated, proves the strengths to outdo the weaknesses. Conclusion Basing on the researches findings, it was concluded that no single intervention whether community or prison based is effective in addressing the issue of drug abuse treatment to offenders. Hence in reiterating the main purpose of this paper, there is no practice that qualifies as best in substance abuse treatment for criminal offenders. The different models must be incorporated to run alternately since all practices show considerably same success margin. References Andrews, A., Bonta, J., & Hoge, R. (1990). Classification for Effective Rehabilitation: Rediscovering Psychology. Criminal Justice and Behavior. 17, 19-52. Anglin, M.D., & Hser, Y. (1991). Treatment of Drug Abuse. In Tonry, M. & Wilson, J. (eds.), Drugs and Crime. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Bryant, J., Etheridge, R., &Hubbard, L. (2000). Process Evaluation Of The RSAT State Alliance For Recovery and General Education (SARGE) Program, Draft Report. Butzin, C. A., Scarpitti, F., Nielsen, L., Martin, S., & Inciardi., J. (1999). Measuring the Impact of Drug Treatment; Beyond Relapse and Recidivism. Corrections Management Quarterly, 3 (4), pp. 1-7. CSAT (1995). Planning for Alcohol and Other Drug Abuse Treatment for Adults in the Criminal Justice System. U. S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. Harrell, A. (2001). The Impact of Jacksonville’s breaking the Cycle Demonstration on Drug Use and Crime: Findings from Offender Interviews. Urban Institute Report. Hubbard, R., Collins, J., Rachal, V., & Cavanaugh, R. (1988). The Criminal Justice Client in Drug Abuse Treatment. In C.G. Leukefel and F.M. Tims (eds.), Compulsory Treatment of Drug Abuse: Research and Clinical Practice. Research Monograph Series 86. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse. Kennedy, S. (1999) The BTC Review, Issue 2. U. S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, National Institute of Justice. Lightfoot, L., & Hodgins, D. (1988). A survey of Alcohol and Drug Problems in Incarcerated Candian Offenders. International Journal of the Addictions. 23 (7), 687-706. MacKenzie, D., & Hickman, L. (1998). What Works in Corrections? An Examination of the Effectiveness of the Type of Rehabilitation Programs Offered by Washington State Department of Corrections. University of Maryland. Parks, G., & Marlatt, A. (1999), Keeping “What Works” Working: Cognitive Behavioral Relapse Prevention Therapy with Substance Abusing Offenders. In Latessa (ed) Strategic Solutions: The International Community Corrections Association Examines Substance Abuse. American Correctional Association. Pearce, S., & Holbrook, D. (2002) Research Findings And Best Practices In Substance Abuse Treatment For Offenders. North Carolina Department of Correction Substance Abuse Advisory Council Simpson, D., Knight, L. (1997). Research Focus of the IBR at TCU. Research Summary, Special Issue April, 1997. Taxman, F. (1998). Reducing Recidivism Through a Seamless System of Care: Components of Effective Treatment, Supervision, and Transition Services in the Community. Office of National Drug Control Policy Conference. Washington, D.C. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders Research Paper, n.d.)
Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/sociology/2059052-see-the-attached-file-there-are-a-number-of-topics-that-you-have-select-one-of-them
(Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders Research Paper)
Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/sociology/2059052-see-the-attached-file-there-are-a-number-of-topics-that-you-have-select-one-of-them.
“Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders Research Paper”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/2059052-see-the-attached-file-there-are-a-number-of-topics-that-you-have-select-one-of-them.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Best Practices in Substance Abuse Treatment for Offenders by Pearce and Holbrook

Substance abuse prevention and treatment agency

The problem of drug and substance abuse is widespread across the world.... Drug and substance abuse has affected the economy by increasing the cost of healthcare, reducing the number of active contributors to the economy and promoting illegal activities.... The drug and substance abuse problem has prompted the emergence of government and non-government organizations to help curb the problem.... … The mission of the Agency is to reduce the effect of substance abuse in Nevada....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Substance Abuse Treatment

In the paper “substance abuse treatment” the author analyzes the issue that court-mandated treatment works as well as voluntary treatment.... How does treatment for an employee help the employerEmployees are a vital part of any business.... In making provisions for the employee, the others see that the employer made a big investment in providing treatment for the employee, he could secure his loyalty for the next 20 years.... At GCASA approximately 45% of the clients admitted are mandated by the criminal justice system to attend treatment having been referred by drug court....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Offenders Rights CJ202

arious legislations and policies that have been put in place to carter for offenders include; the offenders being given religious freedom, ethnic and cultural practice.... offenders rights ranged from right of a public trial to right of counsel to the right of appeal are well stipulated in the national… On the other hand, victims rights are only included one international body-the UN declaration endorsing justice for the victims of abuse of power and crime....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Substance Abuse

Y, (2010), “Clinical Manual of Adolescent substance abuse treatment”, American Psychiatric Pub.... … substance abuse refers to the use of illegal drugs in order to alter mood or get rid of stresses of life.... When people use the word substance abuse, they usually refer to the use of illegal drugs by different people.... Health Sciences of the of the Health Sciences substance abuse substance abuse refers to the use of illegal drugs in order to alter mood or get rid of stresses of life....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Substance abuse

The people involved in substance abuse, like marijuana for recreational purposes have the ability to alter their moods, relax and attain certain levels of euphoria.... Immanuel Kant's categorical imperative can be used to resolve the dilemma developed by substance abuse.... These people are doing substance abuse with genuine intention hence they pass the first theory of deontology.... People abuse the drug with… People claim that though they obtain the drug illegally they use it for a good course....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Treatment of criminal offenders

Clinical treatment of offenders is a delicate program with abundant variables to be considered before implementing and administering to an individual.... In addition, treatment must be determined by the type of medication, dosage, side effects and threats Treatment of Criminal offenders Clinical treatment of offenders is a delicate program with abundant variables to be considered before implementing and administering to an individual.... Social service organizations have attempted to carry out comprehensive data based analysis and surveys on proven clinical treatment to offenders but there is still no documented proof that it actually works (Cole, 2011)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Substance Abuse Treatment Program in North Dakota

Conditions under Which I Would Recommend Drug treatment for offenders Facing Drug Charges Offenders facing drug charges are to be treated immediately they are established to be addicted to hard drugs such as narcotics and are brought under prison custody.... This paper "The substance abuse treatment Program in North Dakota" focuses on the substance abuse treatment program in North Dakota of choice is Drake Counseling Services which is situated in Grand Forks....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Balancing sex offender treatment with community risks

The dynamic factors to put into consideration include anti-social attitudes, and substance abuse.... The dynamic factors to put into consideration include… offenders who are categorized as high risk should receive a more intensive intervention. This principle carries out an assessment of the criminogenic needs, and thereafter targets them for treatment.... offenders who are categorized as high risk should receive a more intensive intervention....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us