StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin et al (2012) in the Journal of American College Health focuses at analyzing the implications of smoking in the United States. With more than 450,000 deaths in 2005 due to smoking, the authors…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin"

The paper “Measuring Compliance with Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin" is a engrossing example of an article on social science. This article published in the Journal of American College Health analyzes the implications of smoking in the US. With more than 450,000 deaths in 2005 due to smoking, the authors indicate that the behavior has become a challenge among the school-going youth. While first-hand smoking has notable negative effects on the health of the smokers, second-hand smoking according to the article is also a major public health threat.

For example, individuals exposed to short-term second-hand smoking are placed at approximately 80% to 90% on the risk of first-hand smoking. On their studies, the authors use the University of Kentucky Chandler Medical Center, which implemented a tobacco-free campus policy in 2008. With the introduction of free tobacco zones and non-restricted areas such as gutters, medians, and sidewalks, the researchers aimed at analyzing the level of compliance by the students. To measure compliance, the authors indicate that investigators adopt various approaches.

For example, Harris and colleagues studies’ covered smoke-free university policy that prohibited smoking within 25 feet from the building.The major objective of this study is to indicate the feasibility as well as psychometric testing of applying Tobacco-Free Compliance Assessment Tool (TF-CAT) to measure the compliance with the smoking policy that was introduced in the university. This entailed undertaking an investigation of the concurrent validity of the TF-CAT using cigarette butts.

The study also focused on describing the feasibility of using TF-CAT. The study used a pilot study that involved newly designed TF-CAT and a phase that included baseline data collection. The sample included was made up of observation periods in secondary locations including steps outside the north entrance and parking lots. Primary locations, which included specific buildings, were also used for data collection. Once the TF-CAT was developed, the study applied cigarette butts as well as observation of smokers as the main indicators of noncompliance.

During the first 8 weeks of the study, which made up the phase 1, there were 296 observation periods. This was followed by 117 observational periods during phase 2 Amanda, F et al, (2012). Apart from the crew’s cleaning schedule, the study used other variables such as time of the day, coverage of the area by the smoking policy, temperature, wind speed, precipitation as well as humidity. One of the major aspects that were applied in the study during data analysis as indicated in the article is the Geographical Information System.

This technology was applied to locate the geographical location of the cigarette butts. In addition, SPSS version 17 was used to conduct the statistical analysis to determine whether there was a statistically significant difference in the number of cigarette butts in the region covered by the policy as compared to areas not covered. The validity of the study indicated that on the main campus, there was no statistical difference between cigarette butts found in violation and non-violation areas.

One of the notable limitations of the use of TF-CAT as outlined in the article is that it assumed that cigarette butts were only discarded on the ground. It was possible that some butts were disposed in the trash can and the investigators could not trace them. Additionally, TF-CAT could not provide the data conducive to privacy in addition to being a method that does not involve spitless or smokeless tobacco. The article concludes that even though TF-CAT is a useful tool to monitor compliance, future studies are required to measure its feasibility and efficacy.

Critical analysisThe article Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy asked the right question. It is vital to note that once a smoking policy is introduced, some smokers do not comply and thus the need to identify the implications of such policies. As indicated by Anderson JE in the article Public Policymaking, once a policy is introduced in any society, the tendency to act contrary to it is experienced. Even though the article covered the major issues that made it come up with the conclusion, it failed to indicate the implication of the smoking policy on the emerging of new smokers.

The problems found in the article matched the methods since the use of the investigators was effective in attaining the inner and private details from the smokers. Given the use of tables, for example, the one that indicates cigarette butts in violation versus non-violation sites, the findings of the article were consistent and used clear format. Even though TF-CAT is effective tool, this article agrees that it has limitation and there is a need for future research on its applicability. Additionally, the article indicates that there are other options that can be used to measure compliance and which it did not consider such as patients, visitors, and employees.

Amanda Fallin et al made clear claims and the convincing data from the observations made them make a better conclusive. According to my opinion, I agreed with the thesis of the article and the findings since it was done by the use of significant sample size and scientific procedures as well as SPSS technology. If the research was conducted by involving other options like visitors, perhaps the findings could have been more reliable. 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin Article - 4, n.d.)
Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin Article - 4. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1879052-article-analysis
(Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin Article - 4)
Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin Article - 4. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1879052-article-analysis.
“Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin Article - 4”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1879052-article-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Measuring Compliance With Tobacco-Free Campus Policy by Amanda Fallin

Riordan Corporate Compliance Plan

The author states that Riordan Manufacturers can ensure effective risk management in the company involving all the employees of the organization.... Individuals should be allowed to give different suggestions that can be followed to ensure effective risk management in the company.... nbsp;… The employees of Riordan Company should adhere to a number of international rules and regulations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Tobacco Shop Franchising

As the Pipe Dreams has been around for eight years and has established a network of franchisees, of which it is known that they have had a high success rate in the past, one can be certain the franchisor has proved that the chosen layout and location of the tobacco shops, the developed pricing policy and assortment of the tobacco goods offered are successful....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Campus Crew Customer Communication

As a function of this, this brief analysis will consider the customer communication strategy for campus crew in Peterborough Ontario.... ue to this particular understanding of the customer communication strategy, the Peterborough Ontario campus crew has a limited scope and interaction with the end consumer.... Whereas other aspects of the business cycle integrate directly with the consumer and expressly state their function/purpose/and service offerings, the campus crew is non-proactive and its offerings and services to the end consumer are merely taken for granted (Hennig-Thurau 57)....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

PSY2000 Perspectives on Free-Speech Zones on College Campuses

The existing freedom of speech policy compares to a great extent with that of West Virginia University.... Every university has a law or policy regarding code of conduct, which establishes or dictates behavioral standards pertaining to students, student organization, teaching staff, and the subordinate staffs (Pavela, 2008).... He continues to say that all the entire campus should be a free speech zone.... The policies dictate the distinct places within the campus where students can hold regular meetings and rallies....
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework

Smoking Tobacco

Across the world, the consumption of tobacco and related products exhibits diverse and dynamic practices that are relevant to the global trade system.... Parker's text explores… This article takes into account statistical developments over a long period.... Most importantly, Parker considers the distribution of smoking behaviors within and across different Smoking Tobacco Parker, Philip....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

A part of an outline for security on campus paper

However, they will be issued with a privacy policy from the campus that will indicate the records will only be used for security purposes (Phaneuf 48).... Enquiring from them means that the security improvement measures will be appreciated and taken seriously by the students. The researcher knows that problems regarding Outline for Security on campus Objectives and Accomplishments Sustaining a safe environment on campus cannot learn when they feel they are unsafe....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Campus BikeShare

The opportunity is exciting as it will present the campus students with a cost effective mode of transport while utilising various forms of technological elements in conducting the business.... hellip; The venture encompasses many elements into a single aspect. The entrepreneur has been previously involved in cycling activities and understand the Task campus Bike Share Entrepreneur and Management The opportunity is exciting as it will present the campus with a cost effective mode of transport while utilising various forms of technological elements in conducting the business....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Snow Days on Campus

Therefore, the severity thus determines the effect it has on the campus staff and students....  The writer of this essay considers an even occurrence at various universities around the United States such as snow day's emails.... Finally, the snow days affect both the students and staffs in the college....
2 Pages (500 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us