StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

French revolution and Enlightenment - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
How much of the political ideals of the Enlightenment were reflected in the revolution? Do you agree with the contention that all the revolution achieved was the replacement of one ruling elite with…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
French revolution and Enlightenment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "French revolution and Enlightenment"

Give a critical perspective on the events that led to the French Revolution. How much of the political ideals of the Enlightenment were reflected in the revolution? Do you agree with the contention that all the revolution achieved was the replacement of one ruling elite with another?The French Revolution is considered by many historians to be the first modern revolution in history. It did not only overthrow the existing leaders but, most importantly, it also change the existing structure of society.

Moreover, even if the Revolution was initiated by the privileged, power and the control of the Revolution was passed on from the privileged class to the middle class, and then, temporarily, to the poor and extreme – the sans-cullotes in Paris. It is in this sense that the French Revolution of 1789, which lasted for ten years, is hailed by historians as an event which changed societies.The idea of nationalism, as known in modern times, was a product of the French Revolution. It also provided the empirical data from which Karl Marx, among others, based his theory of modern revolution.

Moreover, it served as an important model for succeeding revolutions that changed the rest of the world.Most historians would consider the political ideals of the Enlightenment as the driving force behind the Revolution. Some, such as Burke, even went as far as including Rousseau and his philosophy. Rousseau’s book, The Social Contract, is considered the Bible of many leaders of the French Revolution (Russell, 1945). Russell also states that Robespierre’s reign is the fruit of Rousseau’s teaching.

Moreover, he also holds Rousseau’s ideas partly responsible for the dictatorships of Russia and Germany. Specifically, he writes, “Hitler is an outcome of Rousseau.”Even if Rousseau’s ideas did bring about Robespierre’s reign of Terror, wherein thousands were executed for alleged crimes against the Revolution, and the dictatorships of Russia and Germany, he did advocate democracy. Our modern idea of democracy is what he calls elective aristocracy and this, for him, is the best form of government.

However, he points out that this is not for all countries. His idea of democracy, no doubt, was the thread that connected him to the French Revolution. Eventually, the idea of democracy brought about the downfall of monarchy in France.According to Karl Marx, all the Revolution did was replace the feudal economic system of France with that of a capitalistic system, which reinforced the peasantry. It is at this point that one may express dissent. A capitalistic society does not automatically reinforce peasantry.

It can be said that peasantry is an unnecessary result of the shift from a monarchy to a democracy. It may seem at first that peasantry was strengthened after the Revolution. All it may have done is replace the existing rulers by a different set of elites. No one can blame the historians for adopting this point of view. After all, it is always likely for anyone to blame the doctor if, after intensive treatment, a patient remains or becomes even sicker. However, historians who take this position may be blamed for not peeking from the other side.

By overthrowing the monarchy, which sustains the peasantry, the Revolution overthrew the system that maintains the existence of the poor. However, it does not logically follow that the peasant class will also disappear. Indeed, the poor remained poor, and some even poorer. This is not the merit of the French Revolution.The greatness of the French Revolution lies in fact that it eliminated a rigid system that kept the poor class poor. In medicine, an intensive cancer treatment does not automatically make a sick person feel better.

After radiation treatments and chemotherapy, cancer patients may actually feel worse. However, this opens up the possibility of cure. It does not keep the patient sick but gives him/her a chance to be better. If the patient retains the old habits, he/she may go back to being sick. The beauty of America does not lie in the idea that there are no poor Americans because, on the contrary, there are. It lies in the fact that, in America, everyone has the opportunity to change his/her economic status, though it may not always be equal in all aspects.

This is the point of the Revolution. It may have replaced the existing rulers with another elite class but it abolished a rigid system that maintained the poor class. Moreover, by replacing the feudal economic system with a capitalistic system, opportunities are brought to the peasantry to change their social status. However, these are just opportunities, only potential and not actuality. The poor remains poor not because they are not given opportunities but because of their mode of thought. At this point, it stops being a social-political problem and begins as a social psychological problem.

REFERENCES:Russell, B. (1945). A History of Western Philosophy. Simon and Schuster: New York.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“French revolution and Enlightenment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1554362-french-revolution-and-enlightenment
(French Revolution and Enlightenment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1554362-french-revolution-and-enlightenment.
“French Revolution and Enlightenment Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1554362-french-revolution-and-enlightenment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF French revolution and Enlightenment

The Outcome of the French Revolution

Name: Instructor: Course: Date: french revolution The french revolution also gets known as the revolution of 1789.... The french revolution served an unexpected blow to the nobles.... The french revolution did not only impact and shape the political arena in France; the revolution had a far reaching political consequence on the continent of Europe too.... The first changes that the revolution brought about was in 1789 and thus the revolution gets commonly referred to as the ‘revolution of 1789' (Hunt 36)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Classical Social Theory

Thus the bitterness of the French enlightenment critique of the traditional Church is not entirely replicated in the religious thought of the English enlightenment.... hellip; This distinction prompted Ernst Cassirer to remark that, although the German and English enlightenments pose problems for a traditional view of enlightenment as defined by a "critical and skeptical attitude toward religion," the French enlightenment uniquely appears to confirm such a view. In Condorcet's historical account of the heroic march of human reason, it is invariably priestly deception and barbarity which threatens future progress or plunges mankind into lengthy periods of darkness and ignorance....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

French R 1/evolution and Paine

Causes of french revolution had been mulled over and over for centuries now and they still remain fresh to be explored.... Paine, wrote in 1791 a reply to Reflections on the Revolution in France by Edmund Burke, actually defended the french revolution by saying that the revolution was necessary to bring in equality and human liberty, which have been deprived for a very long time in France.... , ambitions of rising bourgeoisie, aggrieved fate of farmers and wage earners, influence of ideas of enlightenment mainly from Rousseau and Voltaire, intolerance of absolute monarchy, arrogance and prerogatives of nobility and unquestioned and unchallenged authority of Roman Catholic clergy were all reasons for the revolution....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The French Revolution and the Cultural Renewal of Europe

The paper “The french revolution and the Cultural Renewal of Europe” will discuss the French Revolution, which altered the cultural sensibilities of Europe's nation states as well as the continent's traditional political power structure.... nbsp;… The author states that the french revolution had a tidal wave effect on Western society.... The power of enlightenment thinking took solid root on both sides of the Atlantic, inspiring political and cultural leaders to adopt the cause of liberty, equality and fraternity as their own....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Enlightenment, Revolution, and Democracy

With careful consideration, one might draw the conclusion that the french revolution and the Enlightenment created a mutual influence that resulted in the central ideals and visions that fed the Revolution, perpetuated it, and gave it thoughts that were put into practice.... One might even go as far as saying that the ideals presented by the Enlightenment and its philosophers were… Currently, there exists a debate regarding the actual influence of the Enlightenment on the french revolution, and the extent of its presence during and after the Revolution One can hardly deny that there was some influence, but whether the Enlightenment was the primary reason for the french revolution, or even significantly influenced it, is under question, though there can be no doubt that Enlightenment ideals and thoughts were put into practice during the french revolution....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Enlightenment in the French Revolution

In order to fully understand the topic in question, the meaning of the word enlightenment needs to be expounded on in order to understand it in the context of the times of the french revolution.... He states that the motto of enlightenment is to dare to know, The french revolution began as a result of several influences such as the scientific revolution which was rooted in gaining scientific knowledge and making major leaps in the field of science.... Therefore, we can conclude that enlightenment was seen as a significant influence on the french revolution....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Terror of the French Revolution

David Roche Provides in his book, a systematic and explicit occurrence during the french revolution and expresses his opinion on the expansion of societal needs.... Scott Haine (6 The French of revolution and Napoleon) Analysis 3 Quotes from the Terror by David Anderson “it is the French Revolution that invented the technique subsequently adopted by all usurping regimes from 1717 St Petersburg to 1790s Santiago; mob terror for seizing power, bureaucratic terror for consolidating it” (14)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

18th Century Dress for Women in France

The prime purpose of this paper is to explore how french fashion for women has become prevalent in shaping European dresses.... The french fashion at the time of Rococo and Regency is described by an assured, well-lit and pastel freedom of mind.... The emergence of the Rococo style initiated in french interior and architectural design.... It is quite surprising to see that there was no room for important french artists like Jean-Baptiste pater and Edme Bouchardon....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us