StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Utopia and Lies in Plato's Republic - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This short paper will attempt to answer the question why Plato’s best city is based on lies. It will investigate the concept of the ‘noble lie’ and the censorship in the education of the guardians of the city – one of the three groups, in which Plato divides his imagined society. …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Utopia and Lies in Platos Republic
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Utopia and Lies in Plato's Republic"

?Topic Why does the best in Plato’s Republic depend on lies? Consider the censorship required in the education of the guardians and the noblelie on which the city is founded. Utopia and Lies in Plato’s Republic Plato’s Republic provides fundamental concepts on the organization of the state, the execution of policy and the personal and societal values, on which they are based. In his most celebrated and studied dialogue, Plato introduces the concept of justice, the stratification of society and the distribution of power in his imagined community. Long before Thomas More and Tommaso Campanella, Plato contemplates the idea of the perfect city, which is an embodiment of the justly organized state, in the context of utopian society. Plato conveys concepts, which modern political scientists relate to the study of collectivism, the welfare state and communalism. His views on the connection between knowledge, virtue, and wisdom, surpass the confinement of philosophy as a discourse. In his Republic, they exist in an amalgamated entity, which is to become the basis of the modern state. This short paper will attempt to answer the question why Plato’s best city is based on lies. It will investigate the concept of the ‘noble lie’ and the censorship in the education of the guardians of the city – one of the three groups, in which Plato divides his imagined society. It will also critically approach Plato’s City in the context of the utopian society, and its existence as a political arrangement. In books III-IV Plato gradually conveys the idea of the perfect city, which is theoretical and is based on ‘noble lie’. The noble lie in the context of the Republic can also be understood as a myth, which has been created as a part of a philosophical discourse. In order to become loyal to the imagined state, the people in Plato’s Republic are told a noble lie, which is the basis of the utopian society the author describes. The noble lie is related with the stratification of society and the “different metals”, which the Gods pour into people’s souls (415a). The noble lie is therefore internalized by the people – a transformation, which soon has productive, rather than suppressive power (Foucault 1984, Shorey 1933, Hyland 1968). In this sense, the best city in the Republic is based on the notion of the invisible ideal, which would transform people’s potential to build into the material force of the state. As Desmond Lee argues, Plato’s noble lie exists as a myth, which has been accepted by all the members of the society. It was not designed for the purposes of mass deception or propaganda, but in order to re-establish the ideas, on which the Platonic society is based (Plato, transl. by Lee, 1979, 370-380, Popper 1945, Strauss 1987). As a result, the idea of the City becomes a discursive system, which is later transformed into a system of knowledge and becomes truth. Here it is important to draw a line between the noble lie, on which Plato’s best city rests, and the fabricated lie, which is related to propaganda in modern political discourse. In the beginning of Book V, Plato conveys basic ideas, related to the social and economic order of his City. He reveals the notions of collectivism, and common societal values for good and evil: Can there be any greater evil than discord and distraction and plurality where unity ought to reign? or any greater good than the bond of unity? […] And there is unity where there is community of pleasures and pains --where all the citizens are glad or grieved on the same occasions of joy and sorrow? […]Yes; and where there is no common but only private feeling a State is disorganized --when you have one half of the world triumphing and the other plunged in grief at the same events happening to the city or the citizens? […] Such differences commonly originate in a disagreement about the use of the terms 'mine' and 'not mine,' 'his' and 'not his.' (305a). The economic ideals of Plato’s best city are presented here in the absence of division of property and ownership. Based on his noble lie, Plato conveys the ideas of collectivism as a source of tranquillity and peace within the City, as well as the shared societal values of what is good and what is evil. Plato’s Utopia in this sense is based on the “the bond of unity”, which comes from the collectivization of pleasures and pains. In order to become loyal to the ideas of collectivism, on which the City is based, citizens need to believe that a domain of common values and beliefs exists. Plato’s theoretical city is based on a noble lie, which requires the de-personification of values, and their communalization. In this sense, Plato’s order of things as articulated in the Republic can be associated with modern political ideologies, such as socialism and communism. The main difference between Platonic utopianism and socialism is that the latter is not based on moral philosophy, but on a communalised mode of production. In addition, socialism falsely assumes, that individuals should be equal, and fails to acknowledge the different extent of their abilities and talents. On the contrary, the Platonic vision of ability is primordial, which serves as the basis for the stratification of society in the Republic. In this brief discussion on the notion of Plato’s Noble lie, it is important to mention his tripartite model of the society. Plato divides society in three classes – the workers/consumers, the military and the guardians. Of the three, the role of the guardians is the most important for understanding the main argument, presented in this essay. The guardians are seen by Plato as philosophers, who have the knowledge and wisdom to rule. According to Plato, in order to become fit for their role of guardians, these individuals need to be properly educated (376d; 395c). Proper education, in Plato’s terms, consisted of censorship on poetry and drama materials, which in his views could distort the future guardians’ rational and entirely logical perception of the world. Plato’s suggests that excessive knowledge of fictional characters could lead to self-deception and raise doubts and fears in later life (382b). With his ideas on education and censorship, Plato raises an important question about the intervention of the state in personal matters, and the transformation of his utopian society, into a surveillance society, as described by George Orwell in his novel 1984 (1949). The main difference between surveillance as described by Orwell, and censorship in the Republic is that the first one targeted the subordination of the individuals, and the second one – specialization of education, which is a prerequisite for the stratification of society. Unlike the world of Orwell in 1984, which is based on the exploitation of human potential, the City in Plato’s Republic is designed to turn this potential into a productive force, through the mechanism of specialized education and the stratification of society. The censorship in the education of the guardians can also be related to the philosophy of objectivism, as described by Ayn Rand. In Atlas Shrugged (2007), Rand concludes that reality should be perceived the way it is and any social constructions of this reality are rendered obtrusive for the productivity and rationalism of the individual. Plato’s guardians are led by logic and wisdom, and similarly, their perception of reality should be objective and straightforward. Any fictionalization of this reality could intervene with their rationality of judgement. Therefore censorship in their education is required. This essay has attempted to show why Plato’s best City in the Republic is based on a noble lie. It is designed to create the myth of the existence of an ideal world. The utopian society, which the City represents, is based on the “useful falsehood” that beings are made of different metals, such as gold, silver and bronze, and therefore they need to be assigned a different function in society (415a). In this sense, the Noble lie also serves as a basis for the creation of a political unity and collective identity among the citizens, who are bound by two common believes – that society is divided into three classes, and its members should live in the boundaries of a welfare state. Perhaps one of the biggest merits of the Republic is that it reveals the origins of any political order or system. In modernity, all forms of political content or discontent are based, more or less, on a noble lie, which can also serve as the basis for the formation of national identity, or conflict. For example, American national identity is based on the myth of exceptionalism of the nation and its superiority over other nations. Another example of how a noble lie can be brought to life is the war in Bosnia, which was entirely based on Milosevic’s exploitation of the myth of the greater Serbian identity. These two examples show that Plato’s Noble lie can have constructive, as well as destructive power. Its power is determined by the political and historical context in which it is articulated. Even to this day however, the Noble lie represents the people’s innate need to believe and trust in a superior authority, regardless of its shapes and manifestations.   Bibliography Campanella, Tommaso. The City of the Sun, Text derived from Ideal Commonwealths, P.F. Collier & Son, New York. 1901. Electronic text available online at: http://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/c/campanella/tommaso/c18c/ Accessed [06.10.2011] Foucault, Michel “Truth and Power” in The Foucault Reader, ed. by Paul Rabinow, Pantheon Books: New York, 1984 Hyland, Drew. “Why Plato wrote dialogues,” Philosophy and Rhetoric 1 (1968): 38–50 More, Thomas. Utopia, London: Adamant Media, 2001 Plato, The Republic, London: Penguin Classics, translated by Desmond Lee, Revised edition, 1979 Popper, Karl. The Open Society and Its Enemies, Volume I: Plato, Volume 2: Hegel & Marx, first published by Routledge & Kegan Paul, London, 1945 Orwell, George, 1984. London: Penguin Books, 1949 Rand, Ayn. Atlas Shrugged, London: Penguin Books, 2007 Shorey, Paul. What Plato Said. Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1933, pp. 1–57 Strauss, Leo. "Plato", 33–89 in History of Political Philosophy, ed. Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey, 3rd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1987 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Utopia and Lies in Plato's Republic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Utopia and Lies in Plato's Republic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1432456-why-does-the-best-city-in-platoyies-republic
(Utopia and Lies in Plato'S Republic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Utopia and Lies in Plato'S Republic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/literature/1432456-why-does-the-best-city-in-platoyies-republic.
“Utopia and Lies in Plato'S Republic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1432456-why-does-the-best-city-in-platoyies-republic.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Utopia and Lies in Plato's Republic

Is Concept Of Social Science Inherently Utopian

The utopian concept of the philosophical approach to social science aims to put forth how the entire state and other social factors in it should function, while also putting forth ways and means to achieve this end.... hellip; The philosophy of Social Science provides generally, the ‘Ideal' state of being....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Plato In the Contemporary View

republic has long been known to be a vision of Utopia, sought after by many leaders and systems, yet the very unpredictable character of humanity throws a wrench into the works every time. … What never ceases to capture my attention with Plato is how often quotes from republic appear from time to time in everyday life from father-to-son advice to advertising slogans.... The timelessness of this work is a wonder, since the very fabric (pathos) of humanity is explored and appears to be relatively unchanged over the span of two millennia when republic is read with a relaxed mind. In formulating his rhetorical arguments, Plato launches an invitation to delve deep into the matter at hand; his views on education are startling in their simplicity yet definitely do not fit in with the contemporary views held by our country's First Amendment; in Chapter 2 of republic (trans....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Ideal Society in the Eyes of Locke and Swift

Locke's etymological explanation of "property," lies in his dervation of its meaning that is life, liberty and estate, including one's self.... In Chapter 4 ("Of Slavery") Locke justifies slavery, very much like More's utopia, where slaves are allowed upto a maximum of two per household and they are allowed freedom based on their good behaviour....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Personal Thoughts on Plato: His Writing and Influence

This paper "Personal Thoughts on Plato: His Writing and Influence" discusses Plato as a firm believer in injustice and inequality.... The overwhelming gap between the rich and the poor aids in human inequality; bridging this gap may also lead to overcoming society's lack of justice.... hellip; Plato did his best to stand for what he believed in, the same way that I fight for what I think is morally correct....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Dialogues of Plato: Apology, Crito, Phaedo

hellip; The author states that Plato's The republic is one of the greatest ancient texts that touched on the relation between the individual and the state.... Plato's presentation in the republic shows us that human beings come together and create a community because they recognized that on their own it will be very difficult to satisfy their needs.... Plato's The republic is one of the greatest ancient texts that touched on the relation between the individual and the state....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Why, if At All, Does Green Theory Need Utopianism

The elements that constitute Utopia are the outcome of the deep impact created by plato's republic on More's beliefs.... The desire for utopia is not only universal but also perennial, as the prospect of a better society lies always ahead3.... utopia depicts a fictional island with its own distinctive religion and customs, as conceptualized by Sir Thomas More, who wrote the book utopia in 1516.... There were many features in the Commonwealth of utopia that Thomas More, author, and brilliant humanist, hoped to see incorporated by the English government....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

The Danger of Memesis

From the paper "The Danger of Memesis" it is clear that Mimesis is able to turn heads and make people comprehend what is essentially an art form, putting the likes of Socrates and Plato in a twist.... nbsp;This is one of the reasons why mimesis is seen as something that holds potential value....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Story and Analysis of Plato's Apology

The author of this paper "The Story and Analysis of plato's Apology" discusses the concepts of philology such as Axiology, Epistemology, and Ontology.... The paper analyses philosophical areas linked with the teachings of Socrates in Apology, a particular dialogue in Ancient Greece penned by Plato....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us