StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of judicial selection - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This method is preferred because it enhances independence in the practice of justice. On the contrary, in the civil model, a person is appointed a judge based on his legal…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
The American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of judicial selection
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of judicial selection"

The American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of judicial selection Task American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of judicial selectionIntroduction The American model of judicial selection entails the appointment of judges through an election process. This method is preferred because it enhances independence in the practice of justice. On the contrary, in the civil model, a person is appointed a judge based on his legal knowledge and experience (Whittington, Kelemen & Caldeira, 2008).

Similar to the American model, there are consultations prior to the appointment of the judge in the civil law model. As such, a lawyers’ performance is evaluated before he/she is appointed to serve the public. This piece discusses the legal issues on appointment of judges either by the American model of judicial selection or the civil law model of judicial selection. Ethical issues on the American model of judicial selectionThe selection process in the American model is open and highly unlikely to face interference from the politicians.

Usually, authorities consult before appointing the judges (Whittington, Kelemen & Caldeira, 2008). The nominee ought to have practiced as lawyers before their appointment as judges. The American model has several weaknesses; for instance, the public can foretell who is likely to be appointed as a judge. Moreover, it is a democratic process of selecting judges because it does not interfere with the constitutional court structure. In the process, the supposed judge should be a person of high integrity.

According to Tarr (2009), prior to selection, the candidates list their servings to the public for scrutiny. This provides an opportunity for the public to elect competent judges from a panel of lawyers. Furthermore, in the American model, a candidate has to seek endorsement from non-governmental authorities before their appointment to serve as a judge. For example, in Oregon, an endorsement of the judge by the public signifies credibility in services as a lawyer.Ethical issues on the civil law model of judicial selection The appointing body that uses the civil system has a wide selection to choose from as opposed to the American model (Tarr, 2009).

Authorities can incorporate their traditional values to the civil system when appointing judges. The Civil law model focuses on the overall development of the justice system and the society. Countries prefer the model of appointment because it allows for flexibility in the choice of individuals to serve as judges. Moreover, there is anonymity on who will be the judge. However, the public can play a role in the process by influencing the appointments. This can result to unfairness in the delivery of justice to the public.

As such, an extremist can become a judge. Indeed, a civil law model promotes democracy in countries that lack judicial independence. Neubauer & Meinhold (2012) asserts that the system is preferable for countries with few practicing lawyers. Ethical issues on both systemsThe focus is on the competence of a judge in both systems, thus, it is upon the judge to uphold dignity in the delivery of justice. The judges’ integrity and legal capability is imperative in both the processes of appointment.

Indeed, the public is assured that their expectations are being met (Neubauer & Meinhold, 2012). The American system is unique since the populace is capable of removing the judge from office by a vote of no confidence. The experience of a judge is analyzed based on his /her judgments of the past in both models of judicial appointment.ConclusionA country should use a model that institutionalizes the judiciary, thus, ensuring justice to all. Moreover, a model for the appointment of judges should simplify the judicial appointment procedures.

An integration of American model to the civil law model will enhance integrity in judicial system of the United States. Lastly, it is significant to address ethical issues regardless of the model used in appointing judges to promote fairness in the society.ReferencesNeubauer, D. W., & Meinhold, S. S. (2012). Judicial process: Law, courts, and politics in the United States. Boston, MA: Wadsworth Cengage Learning.Tarr, G. A. (2009). Judicial process and judicial policymaking. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Pub.

CoWhittington, K. E., Kelemen, R. D., & Caldeira, G. A. (2008). The Oxford handbook of law and politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of Essay”, n.d.)
The American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1599669-the-american-model-of-judicial-selection-vs-the-civil-law-model-of-judicial-selection
(The American Model of Judicial Selection Vs. The Civil Law Model of Essay)
The American Model of Judicial Selection Vs. The Civil Law Model of Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1599669-the-american-model-of-judicial-selection-vs-the-civil-law-model-of-judicial-selection.
“The American Model of Judicial Selection Vs. The Civil Law Model of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1599669-the-american-model-of-judicial-selection-vs-the-civil-law-model-of-judicial-selection.
  • Cited: 2 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The American model of judicial selection vs. the civil law model of judicial selection

The Issue of Virtue or Citizenship for the New Republic of Antarctica

This model extends a vote to its citizens, according to a formula prescribed by law, and effectively operates on the basis of majority rule.... This model is something of an all-win or all-lose system.... A second model is the constitutional republic.... This model is motivated by a philosophical desire to protect minorities from majority rule.... The goal of the constitutional republic is to temper the potential extremes and abuses of the majority model....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Political Tradition of Great Britain

In the first case we… deal with such fundamental features of legal model of the British state system, as the general suffrage, multi-party system, the rule of the law, separation of powers, regular elections, frequent replacement of political forces in power, i.... At the same time the English nationalism was not ethnic, but civil, it became the basic source of formation of concept "British public"....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Sovereignty In The World Model

The paper "Sovereignty In The World Model" considers basic principles of the model of sovereignty and the system of laws on the example of such developed countries as The United States of America, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Belgium and the European Union.... hellip; Once again, mob fury and unethical elements can be controlled in a federal set up through the means of rule of law.... On the other hand, if we are to compare a federal set up with a dictatorial regime, it would not be incorrect to state that over here, the rule of law is hostile in nature....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Organization of the US Justice System

The paper looks into the US judicial system in terms of its administration and organization, as well as the various issues and concerns that beset it.... Further, this paper presents possible solutions to the issues and concerns, along with an organizational model that would best answer the department's prevalent concerns.... The federal government, as well as each of the forty-nine states, has its own criminal justice system, which all respect the rights of the individual as set forth in the court interpretation of the US Constitution, and as defined in case law (Barnett, 2008)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Legal Environment of Business and Online Commerce in Thailand

The selection of the prime minister is from the members of the House of Representatives.... The Kingdom of Thailand or Ratcha Anachak Thai is classified as an independent country, lies in the heart of Southeast Asia, and bordered by Laos, Myanmar, Cambodia, the Gulf of Thailand, Malaysia, and Andaman Sea....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Democracy in America

Generally saying, after the… In the american continent, especially in the United States of America, democracy upholds equality and freedom.... Without President's consent, the bills that are passed by the congress will not become law.... The President, civil Liberties, the Congress, the Constitution, the Courts and bureaucracy are the basic components of current democratic system in America.... The executive, administrative and judiciary of the government come under the control of american President....
7 Pages (1750 words) Admission/Application Essay

Separation of Powers in the UK

The concept of separation of powers is actually a model of state governance, in which the authority of the state is segmented into varied branches, with each branch being allocated disparate areas of responsibility and the associated and requisite powers, with no branch enjoying a power greater than any other branch.... Either it may mean that the selection of each and every branch is independent of other branches or that no branch is dependent on any other branch for its existence....
10 Pages (2500 words) Dissertation

Civil Liberties, Habeas Corpus, and the War on Terror

The main concern over the years has been to evaluate the civil rights and limit then in a matter of national security.... the civil society and the human rights groups have aimed at advocating for habeas corpus for terror suspects.... Historical events have forced the american government to consider civil rights to foreigners held at their naval bases.... Different administrations have been subject to judicial battles to ensure detainees at the naval base access their fundamental rights....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us