StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Probable Cause to Arrest - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Probable Cause to Arrest” the author assumes a law enforcement officer who has cause to arrest a defendant for armed assault, and he also has probable cause to believe that person is hiding in a third person’s garage, which is attached to the house…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Probable Cause to Arrest
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Probable Cause to Arrest"

1) Assume a law enforcement officer has cause to arrest a defendant for armed assault, and he also has probable cause to believe that person is hiding in a third person's garage, which is attached to the house. What warrants if any does the officer need to enter the garage to arrest the defendant What if the officer is in hot pursuit of the defendant Is known to be injured and unarmed Provide evidence to support your answer. The officer does not need a warrant to enter the garage to arrest the defendant. If the Officer has probable cause to believe the defendant to be armed and dangerous, these would be considered an exigent circumstance1 which merits a warrant less search of the garage to apprehend an armed and dangerous suspect. If the officer is in hot pursuit of the defendant the officer may make a warrant less search of the subject2, but other circumstances need to indicate probable cause to apprehend the suspect or make a warrant less entry into a private home3. Flight alone would not merit probable cause4, but the immediate knowledge of the defendant in flight of a felony such as armed assault would be probable cause and justify an arrest. If the suspect is injured and unarmed then the officer may still enter the garage under the emergency doctrine. Under the emergency doctrine, law enforcement officers may enter a dwelling without a warrant when they reasonably believe that a person within is in need of immediate aid5. If an officer of the law has probable cause to arrest someone for criminal activity a warrant is not need for probable cause id justification to make the arrest. 2) Formulate a set of circumstances in which there is probable cause to search but not arrest, in which there is probable cause to arrest but not probable cause to search, in which there is probable cause to both arrest and to search. Probable Cause to Search but not Arrest At 9:35pm officer McCoy notices a blue sedan parked in the parking lot of Clemency Park. Clemency Park is not open to the public after 9:45pm. Officer McCoy gets out of his cruiser and approaches the blue sedan with the intention of informing the driver that he will not be allowed to be on Park ground including the parking lot in another 10 minutes. Officer McCoy, who is familiar with the smell of marijuana, catches a strong odor of marijuana 3 feet from the blue sedan. The officer takes note that there are no other vehicles in the parking lot and the odor must be coming from the sedan. Officer McCoy approaches the vehicle with his flash light positioned toward the driver side and knocks on the driver side window. The driver rolls down the window. Officer McCoy catches an even stronger sent of marijuana coming from the inside of the vehicle. Upon questioning the driver refuses to answer any of the officer's inquiries. Officer McCoy now has probable cause to search the vehicle. After a search of the driver's person and vehicle Officer McCoy found no drugs or drug paraphernalia or any other contraband. The officer had the right to make a warrant less search but not a warrant less arrest. Probable Cause to Arrest but not Probable Cause to Search Mr. Tomas was distributing pamphlets in the lobby of a Masonic Temple. An authorized representative of the temple asked Mr. Tomas to leave the building. Mr. Thomas refused to leave the building and continued distributing pamphlets. About Ten minutes later two officers arrived by call of the temple representative. The officers asked Mr. Thomas to leave the temple. Mr. Thomas refused to comply with the officer's request. The two officer's subsequently arrested Mr. Thomas on the charge of Trespassing. The officers had probable cause to arrest Mr. Thomas but no cause to search without a warrant. Probable Cause to both Arrest and to Search At 1:15am The 35th precinct had gotten reports from two different calls that gun shots were fired at residence 56 West Elmhurst. The nearest police cruisers responded to the radio dispatch. Three cruisers appeared on the scene and parked in front of the residence. The 6 officers that responded heard 2 gunshots coming from 56 West Elmhurst the residence reported upon. Under these exigent circumstances the officers had the right to enter the dwelling and conduct a search without a warrant. The 6 officers knocked 3 times announced their selves and waited approximately 5 second for an answer. After not getting an answer the police broke down the door and entered the residence. Two men were found in the act of dowsing three bodies in what smelled like gasoline. The offenders were drawn on and apprehended. In this scenario the officers had the right to make a warrant less entry, search, seizure, and arrest. 3) Mr. A walks into a police station drops three wristwatches on a table, and tells an officer that Mr. B robbed a local jewelry store, two weeks ago. Mr. A will not say anything else in response to police questioning. A quick investigation reveals that the three watches were among a number of items stolen, is there cause to do any of the following 1. Arrest Mr. A No. Being that Mr. A gave the stolen good to law enforcement willingly and voluntarily it cannot be said that Mr. A intended to benefit himself or another person with the stolen goods. Therefore no arrest can be made for possession of stolen goods or any other offence. 2. Arrest Mr. B No. There is no probable cause to arrest Mr. B because Mr. A would not furnish the police with any additional information. A statement cannot be drafted with an uncooperative informant. The information is considered reliable but cooperation is needed for the arrest of Mr. B. 3. Search Mr. A's home No. Upon consideration of all the facts there is no probable cause to believe Mr. A committed an offence. There must be probable cause to merit a search warrant. Mr. A has the legal right to refuse to answer any of the officer's questions. 4. Search Mr. B's home No. A mere "Tip" provided by Mr. A is not sufficient enough to issue a search warrant for the home of Mr. B. There is no detailed factual information being provided by Mr. A nor is he a cooperative informant. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Probable Cause to Arrest Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words, n.d.)
Probable Cause to Arrest Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1509444-criminal-law-and-procedure
(Probable Cause to Arrest Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Probable Cause to Arrest Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1509444-criminal-law-and-procedure.
“Probable Cause to Arrest Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/law/1509444-criminal-law-and-procedure.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Probable Cause to Arrest

The Affidavit

There are certain conditions where the officer can have a probable cause to search the property in which the defendant is hiding, but not a Probable Cause to Arrest the defendant.... In the second case, the police have no Probable Cause to Arrest Mr.... In such a situation, the officer can acquire a search warrant based on the probable cause to search the property believed to be abetting the defendant but he or she can not arrest the defendant given that there is not enough reasons to tie the defendant to the crime committed (Albin, 2010)....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Four Motives for Homicide

A homicide can be comprised of one or more of these motives, but it always comes back to the four Rs.... The four Rs are Rape, Rage, Robbery and Random.... More than one of these categories can apply to an individual murder.... For example, a… This paper will examine a homicide dealing with Rape (Josh Bagwell, Curtis Gambill and Randy Lee Wood), Rage (Betty Broderick), Robbery (Diane Borchardt) and Random (Charles Whitman). On October 3, 1996, Heather Rich's parents reported her The Waurika, Oklahoma police were not too concerned at first....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

What Cases Are Police Stops and Frisks Appropriate in

he challenge that the officers encounter during their practice is determining the reasonableness of the circumstance under which an individual should be stopped and frisked in the event that there is a lack of possible cause to arrest....  … Police stop involves a less invasive arrest of an individual whereas a frisk entails a restricted search on an individual stopped by the law enforcing officers.... The police officers can carry out the stops even when an apparent cause for an arrest does not exist....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Criminal Law or Burden of Proof

The term paper "Criminal Law or Burden of Proof" states that Many are the times when people have watched movies and films which dwell on criminal investigations and legal drama.... In these films, the different aspects that are required for the prosecution, arraignment in court.... nbsp; … The paper demonstrates that the burden of proof is something that is less complex in understanding its application but quite hectic in applying it in a court of law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Probable Cause Issues

This means the police Probable cause Probable cause Did the police have Probable Cause to Arrest Ayers In this case, the police did not have a Probable Cause to Arrest Ayers because they had no evidence linking him to the crime.... This means the police had no right to arrest and detain Ayers for several days without a probable cause.... If they had a probable cause, they had the right to arrest him because he would be a great danger to the community around him....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Evolution of Policing and Investigation

A significant Supreme Court ruling that police was not restricted by Fourth Amendment to stop and frisk a person even there is no Probable Cause to Arrest so long as the police is satisfied with a probable... MDP also serves as a local police department performing state, county and Federal roles. Robert is known as the father of the todays policing framework as… The initial Scotland police are affectionately called Bobbies after Roberts name and Peelers (unaffectionate). Include interdisciplinary such as physics, chemistry, mathematics and geology that aid in the analysis of physical evidence of a It is relevant during investigations where one dies of poisoning....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Wolf v. Colorado & Terry v. Ohio Case

nder normal circumstances,the officer had no Probable Cause to Arrest terry for anything.... cceptably according to the rule of law; a police officer may perform a search for weapons without a warrant,without a probable cause when the officer reasonably believes that the person may be armed and dangerous (Atkin,2013).... s the search by an officer for a weapon without a probable cause for arrest an unreasonable search under the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution?...
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Arrest warrants/probable cause/legal searches

Arresting a suspect on probable cause prompts the officer to have an arrest warrant issued on the person for previous crimes.... An arrest warrant is issued after a legal complaint has been placed on the suspect in an enforcement agency such as the police station (Del Carmen, 2006).... When police… s or other authoritative institutions mandated to enforce the law, suspect a person and have viable information to support their cause, a judge can issue a warrant....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us