StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Ecological Revolution - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper provides a comparison between James Burke’s narrative of scientific revolution and Carolyn Merchant’s Ecological Revolution. Both Merchant and Burke are determined to explain how scientific and technological advancement has changed human’s way of life…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Ecological Revolution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Ecological Revolution"

A comparison between James Burke’s narrative of scientific revolution and Carolyn Merchant’s Ecological RevolutionJames Burke’s The Day the Universe Changed is a ten episode documentary television series, which narrates how specific technological and scientific advances have transformed the western way of life. The primary focus of the film is to highlight the effects of science and technology on the western philosophy. For example, episode 04 talks about how printing has transformed knowledge.

The ancient world that relied largely on spoken word and memorized knowledge was significantly changed by Gutenberg’s discovery of printing (Burke @-7:38). The availability of printing machines and papers significantly changed how people stored, memorized and reviewed information. In episode 05, Burke talks about how science has revised the heavens. The main idea presented here is that the heavens do not revolve around the earth. He cites discoveries made by Isaac Newton and Galileo to support his ideas, and further explains how the new created a conflict within the Catholic Church (Burke @-9:00).

Carolyn Merchant in her narrative, Ecological Evolution, explores the process of ecological transformations, which took place in New England as European Settlers assumed control of the land (Merchant 27). She explains how human societies relate to the environment, and how they have changed the environment. This narrative is focused to explain how human gender relations, social structure, and economic regime are influenced by ecological realm of animal and plant life.Both Merchant and Burke are determined to explain how scientific and technological advancement has changed human’s way of life.

Burke describes the effect of science and technological advancements on human philosophy in a positive perspective, while Merchant believes that science and technological advancements have adversely affected environment and its contents in a negative way. For example, Burke narrates that the availability of written materials facilitated the amount of information that people store and remember. It also reduced the level of corruption in the church, since financial statements among other records, were available for audit and verification (Burke @-6:53).

The attempts to end corruption in the Catholic Church also led to the emergence of Lutheran movements. Merchant, on the other hand, explains that Europeans’ exhaustive methods of logging, hunting, and tapping at the onset of increasing urbanization and industrialization, shattered Indian’s integration with their natural world (Merchant 52). In summary, Burke believes that scientific and technological advancements have positively contributed to human developments such as urbanization and industrialization, while Merchant believes that such developments have extremely shattered humans’ integration with their natural environment.

Works CitedBurke J. The Day The Universe Changed – Episode 04: A matter of Fact: Printing Transforms Knowledge. Electronic Retrieved from: http://watchdocumentary.com/watch/the-day-the-universe-changed- episode-04-a-matter-of-fact-printing-transforms-knowledge-video_e042e2ab6.htmlBurke J. The Day The Universe Changed – Episode 04: Infinitely Reasonable: Science Revises the Heavens. ElectronicRetrieved from: http://watchdocumentary.com/watch/the-day-the-universe-changed- episode-05-infinitely-reasonable-science-revises-the-heavens-video_a3c4be0d7.

htmlMerchant C. Ecological revolutions: nature, gender, and science in New England. North Carolina: Univ of North Carolina Press, 2010. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Essay”, n.d.)
James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/technology/1590960-q-please-write-an-compare-and-contrast-essay-about-james-burkes-narrative-of-the-scientific-revolution-with-carolyn-merchants-please-see-the-videos-which-will-help-you-to-write-this-essay-links-1-httpwatchdocumentarycomwatchthe-day
(James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Essay)
James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Essay. https://studentshare.org/technology/1590960-q-please-write-an-compare-and-contrast-essay-about-james-burkes-narrative-of-the-scientific-revolution-with-carolyn-merchants-please-see-the-videos-which-will-help-you-to-write-this-essay-links-1-httpwatchdocumentarycomwatchthe-day.
“James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/technology/1590960-q-please-write-an-compare-and-contrast-essay-about-james-burkes-narrative-of-the-scientific-revolution-with-carolyn-merchants-please-see-the-videos-which-will-help-you-to-write-this-essay-links-1-httpwatchdocumentarycomwatchthe-day.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution and Carolyn Merchants Ecological Revolution

The Structure of Scientific Revolution and Varieties of Religious Experience

This paper is an analytical review on two of the most influential books of the 20th century: The Structure of scientific revolution by Thomas Kuhn (1962) and Varieties of Religious Experience by William James (1902). The first book discusses a detailed history of science, how… Kuhn places special emphasis on what factors actually contributed to a discovery, in this book, rather than discussing the discoveries per se; he believed that no person could be credited with a discovery unless history had been sufficiently studied to conclude the same, because other simultaneous, if inconclusive, theories were taking place also which helped in the structure building and assumptions base of any discovery....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Scientific Revolution Burke vs Merchant

The paper "scientific revolution – Burke vs Merchant" states that Merchant believed that the scientific revolution was in fact the death of nature because scientists so deeply infiltrated with the nature of life that they became a cause of death of the actual nature of life.... James Burkes described scientific revolution as an unstoppable process of change.... He also believed that the scientific revolution is a process of learning laws of nature to estimate it and forecast it accurately....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Narrative Comparison in Scientific and Ecological Revolutions

This paper 'Narrative Comparison in Ecological Revolutions" focuses on the fact that according to both Burke and Merchant, the scientific revolution is the time that witnessed the philosophical change in scientific aspects that transformed western culture.... nbsp;… According to Merchant, the scientific revolution raised the need for man to reflect on the relationship between human beings and the environment.... nbsp; In both Burkes and Merchants narratives, emergency of the scientific revolution as a means of upward progression by humans that could witness them gain power in order to control, rule, and manage the earth while searching the lost Garden of Eden....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Carolyn Merchants Ecological Revolution and James Burkes Narrative of Scientific Revolution

The paper "Carolyn Merchant's Ecological Revolution and James Burke's narrative of scientific revolution" highlights that the key issues that are presented by both Merchant and Burke are that scientific and technological advancements have changed human societies.... A comparison between Carolyn Merchant's ecological revolution And James Burke's narrative of the scientific revolution Carolyn Merchant in her narrative, Ecological Evolution, narrates about the process of ecological transformations that occurred in New England as European Settlers took control of the land (Merchant 67)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The Scientific Revolution

The 16th and 17th centuries were largely marked as an era of scientific revolution, during which new ideas and knowledge in various fields were introduced, including the fields of physics, astronomy, biology, medicine and chemistry.... Historically, the scientific revolution began in Europe towards the end of the Renaissance era.... In particular, the scientific discoveries made by Galileo have paved the way for the science-religion conflict that shaped this era....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Scientific versus Industrial Revolutions

Geocentric revolution is earth-centered while heliocentric is based on the understanding of the… Materialism is based on the view that the mechanistic world is composed of matter and motion.... Geocentric revolution is earth-centered while heliocentric is based on the understanding of the earth's position and movement in the universe.... One revolution preceded the other because every revolution is based on man's need and understanding at that time....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

How does Kuwait follow the stages of Edmund Burke's Theory of Modern Revolutions

To begin with, Dreyer described Edmund Burke as a key philosophical founder of modern conservatism and a representative of classical liberalism who is best known for his steadfast opposition to the French revolution (462-479).... Based on his reflections on the French revolution,… The objective of this present study if to validate the Edmund's theory by showing how Kuwait as a case study has followed through the first stage of the modern revolutions and how it has How Kuwait Followed the Stages of Edmund Burke's Theory of Modern revolution Introduction To begin with, Dreyer described Edmund Burke as a key philosophical founder of modern conservatism and a representative of classical liberalism who is best known for his steadfast opposition to the French revolution (462-479)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Enlightenment and Scientific Revolution

This report "Enlightenment and scientific revolution" discusses the enlightenment revolution that was a pathway to fresh ideas from people who never had the freedom to air their views, especially when they were against the church or the cultural practices of the medieval times.... Enlightenment and the scientific revolution were closely related.... A spirit of curiosity gave rise to a scientific revolution (Burns 2003)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us