StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Keeping Your Head in the Game - Sport-Specific Imagery and Anxiety among Injured Athletes - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper " Keeping Your Head in the Game - Sport-Specific Imagery and Anxiety among Injured Athletes" concludes that it is the responsibility of practitioners to advise injured athletes to use sport-specific imagery especially that which is related to sport-skills and strategies…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Keeping Your Head in the Game - Sport-Specific Imagery and Anxiety among Injured Athletes"

Name: Tutor: Course: Institution: Date: Article Critique The following critique is about the journal article: Keeping Your Head in the Game: Sport-Specific Imagery and Anxiety among Injured Athletes. The article was written by Eva Monsma, PhD; James Mensch, PhD, ATC; and Jeniffer Farroll, MS, ATC and published by the National Athletic Trainers Association, Inc in the Journal of Athletic Training 2009, 44(4) p. 410- 417. The issue discussed here is the issue of sport-specific imagery and the issue of anxiety during rehabilitation. Using an observational design method, the authors’ purpose is to explore sport-specific imagery used during rehabilitation and examine characteristics of athletes and injury with regard to variations in imagery content as well as return-to-practice anxiety. Another purpose of the authors was to compare the frequency of imagery use early in injury rehabilitation with that just before return to practice and examine how image use and return-to-practice anxiety are related. This has been achieved using a Sport Imagery Questionnaire and a Sport Anxiety Scale as the main outcome measures. It was concluded that sport-specific image content in injured athletes is related to return-to-practice anxiety during rehabilitation. This finding made the authors conclude that it is the responsibility of practitioners to advise injured athletes to use sport-specific imagery especially that which is related to sport-skills and strategies. After thoroughly reading the article, it is worth noting that the title of the article, in reference to the content given, is appropriate and clear. While trying not to use many words in the title, the title was appropriate in bringing forth the suspense of how injured athletes can “keep their head in the game”, and clear by explaining that this can be achieved through two things: sport-specific imagery; and anxiety. The article’s abstract is specific and to the point. It is divided into eight sections: the context, objective, design, setting, the participants, the main outcome measures, results obtained and conclusions made. A list of key words is also provided. A brief introduction examines the relevance of the issues discussed in athletic training educational programs. It is also in the introduction that the authors explain the purpose of the article, explaining that sport-specific imagery for facilitating return to play is rarely examined in the context of rehabilitation. This idea was of major concern and the number reason to look for errors of fact and interpretation. The authors have cited a wide variety of references; these were examined in detail to determine errors, of which, it is worth noting, it was revealed that the authors have not misinterpreted or misrepresented any work. The relevance of ideas discussed is of great significance. The authors’ discussion is focused on only the aspects of imagery use and return-to-play anxiety. However, the relevance of some references was questionable. The authors should have used more pertinent references when discussing critical issues. Of concern was quoting the sentiments of the renowned Paivio’s taxonomy used to classify image content into cognitive as well as motivational functions in his work: Cognitive and Motivational functions of imagery in human performance (1985). It is worth noting that there are other more relevant and up to date taxonomies that have been developed to examine sport imagery. This is however not to discredit the innovative work of Paivio, which led to the development of, for example, the Sport Imagery questionnaire. However, it would have been more appropriate for the authors to focus on modern and relevant taxonomies that measure the use of imagery. Paivio’s reference, therefore, is considered inconsequential, and it is recommended that it should be deleted. Various ideas have discussed, some underemphasized while others have been overemphasized. The idea that sport specific imagery that focuses on maintaining sport skills as well as arousal levels among injured athletes has been purposely ignored is a good example of an idea that needs to be revised. This is because this idea has been underemphasized, considering the presence of numerous studies that have been carried out relating to imagery content associated with rehabilitation exercises. In addition, applied models of mental imagery are common, such as the model that was developed by Martin et al that expounds on the importance of using sport specific imagery during rehabilitation; the model stated that positive outcomes, for example confidence, can be achieved by applying sport specific imagery in rehabilitation setting. It is therefore recommended that the idea that sport specific imagery has been ignored be revised and expounded to establish the reasons why this idea could have been ignored, as the authors in these articles try to establish. Some ideas have been overemphasized as well. Top in this list is the idea that interventions that are focused upon reducing anxiety using imagery should be tailored by sex. Certainly, this ideas has been overemphasized, considering that the evidence the authors use to conclude this are some of the study’s findings, one of them being that men use more levels of cognitive imagery associated with skills (CS skills) as well as strategies (CS strategies). Another finding used to land to the conclusion was the finding that men have lower levels of worry and concentration disruption compared to women. These studies cannot be conclusive enough to establish that sex should tailor the interventions geared at reducing anxiety using imagery. This is because these studies have significant errors; the second study, for example, had small effect sizes. This ideology should, therefore, be revised and more work and research carried out to test how effective interventions by sex can be. The manuscript is of the appropriate size, since all important information has been presented in an appropriate structure. However, there are some sections that should be condensed. One of these is the discussion section that presents factors related to the use of imagery and anxiety. This section should be condensed, since the authors have provided more information than is necessary when talking about the use of cs-skills and cs-strategies by men in comparison with women. Other than this section, however, the other sections are appropriate. The clarity of the statements made by the authors in the report was carefully examined to establish if there were ambiguous statements. At the beginning of the report, the statement: “although studies of imagery content related to rehabilitation exercises and healing are quite common” has a significant level of ambiguity. The use of the term “quite” in the statement is ambiguous, as the statement does not clarify how common the studies are or are not. It is worth noting that the statement has not been referenced, which suggests that it is an opinion made by an author on the commonality of studies of imagery content related to rehabilitation exercises and healing. It is also ambiguous for the authors to write that: “however, sport specific imagery content prescriptions or what to image for facilitating return to play is rarely described in any rehabilitation context”. The term “rarely” makes the statement to lack clarity; rarely could mean once or twice, as the authors want us to believe. On the other hand, rarely could mean five times or even ten times. Clarity, in the context of the two examples given above, can be achieved by avoiding the use of words such as ‘quite’ and ‘rarely’ when making statements that are critical for the report. Instead, the authors would have provided figures and made clear statements that explain, for example, the commonality in the former statement. The statement that rehabilitation exercises and healing are quite common can be followed by statistics that proof that indeed, these exercises and healing are common. The same goes for the second statement about the description of sport specific imagery. Instead of writing that sport specific imagery is rarely described the authors should have used statistics to explain what they mean by “rarely”. The two cases of ambiguity aside, the author has been objective when discussing the topic. The report’s main statement is that sport-specific imagery and anxiety are effective for the rehabilitation of injured athletes. This is an arguable statement on the subject of rehabilitation, and one would choose to argue that they are not effective. The thesis of this report, therefore, is debatable, which is a good element of objectivity. Another reason the authors have been objective in this article is because they have researched every statement made and all topic sentences to obtain credible and authoritative sources that support every idea argued. Using this information, the authors have supplied the statements made in each body paragraph and have relied in ideas and models developed by experts, study findings as well as verifiable statistics. To further verify objectivity, the use of first person writing was determined, it is worth noting that there was no first person writings in the report, generalizations as well as assumptions. The ideas developed in the essay were verified and the sources used researched to determine their authenticity. An additional element that characterizes objective writing in this article was the unbiased presentation of ideas and facts. Although the information presented reveals passion from the authors, there are no personal points of view or statements that show emotion. The authors have instead provided a balanced point of view with regard to the effectiveness of imagery and anxiety. The objective of the study is of critical importance to the field of rehabilitation of athletes. Sport-specific imagery and anxiety issues are very important for the mental preparation of athletes. An athlete should not only be prepared physically to return to the pitch, mental preparation is also very important. If an athlete is not prepared mentally to return to the pitch, this can result to decreased confidence, resulting to a decline in performance. Cases of re-injury or additional injury have also been reported for athletes that are reported to be ready physically by their team physician but not mentally ready to return. This could also lead to fear of injury or feelings of stress because of lack of confidence. Guided imagery and related techniques, for example hypnosis, not only improve the performance of athletes during competition, but researchers have established that it is possible to speed up the healing process by maintaining a positive mindset and using specific mental skills and techniques. The incorporation of mental training skills in a rehabilitation training program is therefore a very important consideration that team physicians should consider. An adequate description of the experimental methods used has been provided. For example, a good description of the Sport Imagery Questionnaire has been given, together with all of its subscales: the sport skills scale; the strategies and tactics scale; the goal related outcomes scale; the arousal scale; and the mastery scale. The Sport Anxiety Scale was also adequately described, together with the 4-point Likert scale used to determine reactions to competition. A review of the experimental methods used shows that they are appropriate for the purposes of this study. The Sport Imagery Questionnaire, for example, is effectively modeled for the study and played a critical role in obtaining the findings. It is worth noting that the questionnaire is used to determine the frequency of using images replicated in the Paivio cognitive and motivational functions of imagery. Each of the subscales mentioned helps achieve the objective of the study; they helped analyze and establish the relationship between injury-related variables such as days in rehabilitation, experience, the efficacy of adherence and previous ability efficacy. Conclusion This critical analysis has explored various elements used in Monsma et al’s (2009) article. A number of issues have been discussed, including the relevance of the ideas, the clarity of statements made, the objectivity, the size and appropriateness of the manuscript as well as the appropriateness of the experimental methods used. Cases of ambiguity have been established, as the authors were vague and did not use appropriate statistics to proof the commonality of sport specific imagery studies. Nonetheless, the information was presented in a non-objective and professional way using authoritative and relevant sources. Works Cited Monsma, Eva., James Mensch. and Jeniffer Farroll, Keeping Your Head in the Game: Sport- Specific Imagery and Anxiety among Injured Athletes, The National Athletic Trainers Association, Inc in the Journal of Athletic Training 2009, 44(4) p. 410- 417 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Research Critique Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2021 words, n.d.)
Research Critique Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2021 words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/2046744-research-critique
(Research Critique Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2021 Words)
Research Critique Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2021 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/2046744-research-critique.
“Research Critique Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2021 Words”. https://studentshare.org/psychology/2046744-research-critique.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Keeping Your Head in the Game - Sport-Specific Imagery and Anxiety among Injured Athletes

Health of Athlete: Choice of Specific Factors

The process of running plus kicking the ball desires enough training in order to acquire desired traits as the game requires.... The muscles of the athletes plus the energy systems determine the performance of the athlete.... A paper "Health of Athlete: Choice of Specific Factors" claims that the choice of the athlete is best because he has desired needs for the resistance training program....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Sociology, Media and Sports

Her mother had quoted to him sports such as rugby stating how the players were aggressive which made the game more of a boxing match than a fair competition.... He only prided in watching athletes over the television and had no practical skills of how sporting activities were undertaken yet he could not stop amusing me by the way he expressed his optimism for more women participation in sports....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Negligence in Sports Injuries

For example, in the case of Woolridge v Sumner7 where a spectator was injured, it was held to be the result of an error of judgment rather than negligence.... The governing premise for determining whether negligence has occurred was laid out by Lord Atkin in the case of Donaghue v Stevenson1 in which he stated that "reasonable care" must be taken to "avoid acts or omissions which you can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure your neighbor....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Literature Review- Youth Sports and Binlingual/Spanish-SPeaking Athletes

Literature Review if Applicable) and Number or Project 12 December 2005 Literature Review: Youth Sports and Binlingual/Spanish-Speaking athletes The National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy, which is described in fulldetail at www.... Games Girls Play: Understanding and Guiding Young Female athletes.... Gale uses Joel Fish's book titled, 101 Ways to Be a Terrific Sports Parent: Making Athletics a Positive Experience for your Child as a resource....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Athletics and Endorsments

Corporations believe that elite athletes have specific influence on the purchasing behavior of customers due to popular appeal, and name and face recognition, a substantial reason why they continue to employ cream of the crop sportspersons in endorsements (Delaney and Madigan… For instance, popular appeal makes it to a point that integrity through body image enhances person's appearance to the public.... A superb tennis player like Roger Federer is not unusual among avid tennis aficionados, but he is known for them to play the said game with high Athletics and Endorsements Elite athletes are often used as celebrity endorsers in commercials and print ads....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Sports and society in ancient world

The Greeks are among the best athletes in the world because they specialize in athletics as an art.... The athletic The athletes were usually covered completely in oil in order to magnify their physical attributes and at the same time keep off from gathering dust during competitions.... Its use concerning the question is because athletes were to be flexible and the use of Bronze made this apparent.... The sculpture illustrates that ancient Greek athletes were expected to be religious in tune with their beliefs....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Reduction of Concussions in the Game

In fact, it is only through the prohibition of helmet-to-helmet contact – as part of the game – that concussions can be controlled, i.... The author states that concussion can be characterized as a major problem for athletes in all sports.... However, this measure has been proved inadequate to protect athletes from concussion.... It should be noted that even if different criteria have been used by researchers in order to evaluate the short-term and the long-term effects of concussion, their studies lead to similar assumptions: initiatives should be developed for the control of concussions in football because of their severe effects of the health of athletes....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us