StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Plato's three conditions for knowledge - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Plato, the Father of Western Philosophy, and some philosophers before him, attempted the same dispute and formulated assertions on knowledge. In accordance with Plato’s philosophy, to possess…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Platos three conditions for knowledge
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Plato's three conditions for knowledge"

The paper “Plato's Three Conditions for Knowledge" is a wonderful version of a term paper on philosophy. The definition of knowledge is a subject of unending argument among philosophers. Plato, the Father of Western Philosophy, and some philosophers before him attempted the same dispute and formulated assertions on knowledge. In accordance with Plato’s philosophy, to possess the knowledge, three conditions have to be met, namely belief, true belief and justification.

Belief A belief is basically similar to an opinion. It is one person's perspective that is not essentially supported by facts. An individual may possibly believe that the earth rotates around the moon, or that the tooth fairy does really check each kids pillow every night. That individual might even believe that those are realities. However, with the absence of proof to these facts as more than an assumption, they remain as opinion or belief, instead of knowledge. Fundamentally, beliefs are theories that we have formulated about the world that surrounds us.

Even a belief that turns out to be true does not mechanically become knowledge on the foundation that it is a fact. Here is an example: A contestant in a game show was asked, "Which president was taller, Abe Lincoln or Grover Cleveland?" He guessed the answer: Lincoln. Lincoln was an exceptionally tall man, based on each memory that the contestant had of Lincoln. However, the contestant might not have seen any pictures of Cleveland. That Lincoln was probably taller than Cleveland was a mere opinion of the contestant.

And although he believed that Lincoln was taller than Cleveland, he most likely would not bet on it. In reality, Lincoln was indeed the tallest of all presidents. This made the contestant’s opinion true, on the other hand, just because he had a correct opinion, did not necessarily imply that he knew that fact. Therefore, a correct opinion or true belief cannot be deemed real knowledge (Baker, 2012a). True Belief In Plato’s philosophy, although belief and knowledge are two different things, one is inseparable from the other.

For example, if one says that two plus two equals four, it would be pointless to say that the person knew this truth without accepting it as true. In Plato's principle, knowledge means belief. While an individual should have a belief to have the knowledge, it is likewise a must that it be a true belief. He cannot know something that is false. For sure, it would be impossible to find a person who knows that one plus one equals five, and there is no way he will ever find evidence to support this account as true (Baker, 2012a).

  Justification Justification is the last condition for knowledge, as said by Plato. Lack of validation would mean that it is an only true opinion. Plato terms this justification as a binder and uses in his experiment an analogy of sculptures that will escape if untied. While a rather obscure case, what Plato is implying is that true opinion is short-lived. A belief is a mental state, which can time and again be inconsistent and prone to adjustment. In our example in the first condition for knowledge, the game show contestant who had seen several photographs of Lincoln being extremely tall, unexpectedly remembered that in all pictures of the tall Lincoln, he was actually wearing a hat which made him appear tall.

In view of this recollection, the contestant could begin to hesitate in his belief that Lincoln was taller than Cleveland. Moreover, if the contestant remembered a friend previously stating that Cleveland was a very tall man, he could even change his mind entirely and choose Cleveland as the safer answer. Justification is the sensible validation of one’s true opinion. Without this validation, the true belief that Lincoln is taller than Cleveland is merely a lucky guess or theory. In the same way, if the contestant were to answer Cleveland, he would still just be depending on belief.

What is missing is the consistent information that places the fact of Lincoln as being taller than the fact of Cleveland. This would be the contestant's validation to truly defend his belief that Lincoln was indeed taller. Presenting this rationale, the contestant would probably then be willing to bet on the question: "Which president was taller, Abe Lincoln or Grover Cleveland?" The contestant would now be able to confidently declare, "Lincoln is taller," due to the following reasons: 1.

The statement is true and correct (True). 2. The contestant believes that it is correct (Belief). 3. He is justified in believing that it is correct (Justified).  According to Plato, with all the three conditions met, the contestant would be the proud holder of Knowledge (Baker, 2012a). However, contradicting Plato’s Theory of Knowledge is Gettier’s Theory. Gettier revealed a primary error in Plato's logic. Gettier formed a theoretical situation in which justified true belief falls short in leading to knowledge, thereby causing an assumption that some other components would need to be present so as to possess knowledge.

Even as Gettier acknowledges Platos “justified true belief” as essentials in the possession of knowledge, he believes that an absent element is crucial to account for some situations of accidents making justified true belief devoid of knowledge, as exposed in the Gettier theory (Baker, 2012b).

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Plato's three conditions for knowledge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words, n.d.)
Plato's three conditions for knowledge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1768164-platos-three-conditions-for-knowledge
(Plato'S Three Conditions for Knowledge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Plato'S Three Conditions for Knowledge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1768164-platos-three-conditions-for-knowledge.
“Plato'S Three Conditions for Knowledge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1768164-platos-three-conditions-for-knowledge.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Plato's three conditions for knowledge

The Characters in Jose Saramagos Novel Blindness

(Watt 45-56) Therefore, by referring to this allegory, Plato indicates that knowledge does not merely derive from mere sight of something; rather it derives from logical perception of sight.... In a sense, the novel “Blindness” rather explicates plato's philosophy of reality in the fictive environment of a narrative.... The blindness of Saramago's characters in the novel tends to resemble the inability of plato's cave dwellers.... A brief overview of plato's allegory of the cave and the subsequent analysis will necessarily help a reader to perceive the philosophical significance of ‘blindness' in the novel....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Plato's Republic and Hobbes Leviathan and Elizabeth Anderson

The leaders do not only acquire academic knowledge, but technical knowledge which makes them salient, emotionally betrothed, and consistently entrenched in order to block biases and unconscious stereotypes.... Such leaders are able to create rapport across group-divisions, and to connect in first and second person viewpoint, by drawing upon individual knowledge regarding life, but in a disadvantageous position....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Plato's Republic: The three-part city and the three-part soul

Those who are just and can rule fairly and administer justice will be those who attain pure knowledge and they must be trained as the guardians of justice.... Therefore the indication is that only a man who is just and pure in his soul is likely to… However, since it is not possible what goes on inside one's soul, Socrates first illustrates this concept of justice through the existence of three different kinds of people in a city.... Since it is easier to observe the exercise of justice within an external such as the state, Socrates makes use of the analogy of the city to demonstrate the workings of justice and proposes that an ideal city where justice is thriving will be peopled by three different classes of people : the rulers, the auxiliaries and the followers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Platos Theory of Knowledge

Plato's theory of knowledge is generally referred to as “justified true belief.... ?? This epistemological theory basically states that knowledge is gained through an… There are two very important and basic components to this theory.... A person will not put any effort into attempting to explain something that There is no way to gain knowledge without something actually being believed, in other words.... However, obviously there is not any way to gain knowledge by merely believing something....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Legal Fictions (Plato, Xenophon and Henry David Thoreau)

He found that all made the common error of considering their knowledge of their professions with wisdom; just because they had some… Ans.... He found that all made the common error of considering their knowledge of their professions with wisdom; just because they had some knowledge of politics/poetry/craft they considered themselves wise in other matters, this pretence of wisdom actually proved their foolishness.... He mentions three judges of Hades (the underworld) - Minos, Rhadamanthus and Aeacus....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Taking a Stand

The new specie according to him concentrates over disseminating the available knowledge, for instance, in the contemporary Taking a Stand This paper aims to support the argument that ‘education should not be conducted for cash' on the basis of Rev.... The new specie according to him concentrates over disseminating the available knowledge, for instance, in the contemporary universities there are few knowledgeable engineers who prepare courses to form a degree program....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Highest Object of Knowledge of the Good or Reality

The paper "The Highest Object of knowledge of the Good or Reality" investigates human beings.... Few people acknowledge that murder is wrong due to knowledge.... If plato's support for an ethic of happiness appears rather unresponsive that is because of some varied reasons....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

The Myth of the Cave

Some of the chains holding us in life keep people in the shadow hence denying individuals the capability and the ability to learn how to face the truth and how to face knowledge.... Plato's myth of the cave analyzes closely how individuals do behave while dealing with knowledge in life.... This paper ''The Myth of the Cave'' tells that having been written about 360 BC as part of his excellent work, The Republic is one of plato's clearest allegories....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us