StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Fine-Tuning Argument - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Fine-Tuning Argument " highlights that generally speaking, the fine-tuning argument suggests that in the universe, the conditions that allow life can only come about when: certain universal important physical constants are considered. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
The Fine-Tuning Argument
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Fine-Tuning Argument"

Every day science is discovering new things, so it would be inadequate to conclude that God is omnipotent.  This is a response to the reasoning and responses to the universe hypotheses of the fine-tuning argument (Collins, 3)

I am not convinced by the general principle reasoning. It formulates the fine-tuning argument against the ‘atheistic Single-universe’ hypothesis. It uses the prime principle of confirmation. The confirmation principle states that for two hypotheses H1 and H2. Something counts as evidence for hypotheses rather than another which is when is truer under a certain hypothesis than another (Collins, 8). Therefore in probability, the greater the difference, the greater the probability of counting as evidence. The examples offered in the principle of confirmation are, firstly, find rocks. Whereby if you find rocks in the mountain errand Saying ‘welcome to mountains’ there is a great probability that it is your brother who wrote it rather than chance. Secondly, a defendant's fingerprints found on a murder weapon would more probably suggest that he is the murderer. I do not agree with the application of the principles that rely on the fact that that the universe has the fine-tuned life factors being more probable under the theism hypothesis. The belief that the universe along with the essential life factor is an inexplicable brute fact (Collins, 18). The principle questions whether there are other universes. If there are, then one of the universes has to be fine-tuned. It happens that the only fine-tuned universe could be ours because the other does not support intelligent life.

I am not convinced by the response to many universes' hypothesis because it describes the universe as large or perhaps infinite thus it differs from the fundamental physical parameters. I agree that the majority of the universes do not support life-permitting values only one. It's hard to understand the existence of an improbable universe such as ours. The response also uses the oscillating big bang theory whereby, it suggests that the universe came into existence 10-15 billion years ago in an explosion. It goes further and states that our universe will eventually collapse and go back to its original form. Later the big bang will reoccur in another universe and so on (Collins, 23). Personally, I think the big bang theory is unreasonable because the parameters of physics are assumed to be reset randomly in the beginning. It explains that collapse and explosion will go on for eternity thus a fine-tuned universe will occur. I agree with the argument made by Collins against the many universe hypotheses. He prefers natural extrapolations and suggests that many universe assumptions are null.

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Can you follow the reasoning of the Fine Tuning Argument Are you Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1689978-can-you-follow-the-reasoning-of-the-fine-tuning-argument-are-you-convinced-by-itaposs-reasoning-and-itaposs-response-to-many-universes-hypotheses-why-or-why-not
(Can You Follow the Reasoning of the Fine Tuning Argument Are You Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1689978-can-you-follow-the-reasoning-of-the-fine-tuning-argument-are-you-convinced-by-itaposs-reasoning-and-itaposs-response-to-many-universes-hypotheses-why-or-why-not.
“Can You Follow the Reasoning of the Fine Tuning Argument Are You Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1689978-can-you-follow-the-reasoning-of-the-fine-tuning-argument-are-you-convinced-by-itaposs-reasoning-and-itaposs-response-to-many-universes-hypotheses-why-or-why-not.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Fine-Tuning Argument

The Argument from Different Sides about the Existence of God

The paper "The argument from Different Sides about the Existence of God" tells that scholars and philosophers have made varied arguments in favor and against the existence of god time to time.... A teleology argument is also addressed as a design argument.... According to this argument, the purpose and design are quite apparent in nature and there has to be a designer called God in common parlance.... Thomas Aquinas also made use of the teleological argument to prove the existence of God....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Fine Tuning Argument

Fine Tuning argument Student's The Fine Tuning argument Fine tuning argument postulates that there are particular set of cosmological factors or important physical constants which are in such a way that if they had been different slightly, then the universe would not have intelligent and therefore it could not support life (Van Inwagen, 1993).... An example of the fine tuning argument is one that describes that in the classical big bang theory, the expansion speed seemed to have been fine-tuned....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

How persuasive are the design arguments

This argument is also called fine-tuning argument.... The argument from design was widely discussed and serves as a foundation of the modern science.... Taking into account the reasoning from design, or teleological argument, the design that was discovered in the universe gave reason to talk about subsistence of the intelligent creator that is usually depicted as God.... By this statement Darwin doubted the Paley's idea about the biological base of argument to design to a considerable degree....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Understanding Argument

Her argument is based on the idea that the National Rifle Association of America and the pro-gun lobby, although a small.... In this article she explores The author's argument can be summarised in one sentence as follows; Guns should be banned for civilians in the United States because they are too dangerous and kill too many people to be safe for non-professionals to use.... vins then moves on to the argument that things other than guns kill people, but they are not made illegal....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Buying Patterns of the Consumers

This paper 'The Buying Patterns of the Consumers' tries to prove the statement that only when businesses have the proper knowledge about the buying patterns of their consumers, they can sustain their revenues and ensure that they rank high in terms of customer satisfaction.... ... ... ... The author states that understanding the behavior of customers allows companies to charge a premium price for their products and strengthen themselves financially....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

What Is an Argument

A sound argument comprises of reasons that are all valid and have true premises.... However, a valid argument is simply a deductive analysis and may sometimes be based on invalid reasoning.... e objects that if Anselm's argument is to be considered and accepted, then all other sound...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Metaphysics: The Teleological Argument

The paper mainly concentrates on the fine-tuning aspect of this whole argument with respect to the criticisms raised against it and other alternative explanations provided.... This work "Metaphysics: The Teleological argument" describes the aspects of the teleological argument by William Paley.... He argued – indeed quite persuasively that his arguments even convinced Darwin until he came up with his famous discovery and stated that 'the old argument fails' – that the sight of a watch sitting in a natural setting invokes questions in our mind about its maker....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

The Problem of Good and Evil

he author's set of three criticisms follow the 'argument from Evil' begin by setting up Johnson's overall position: taking the example of the suffering baby in a house fire, God had the ability to save the child but failed to do so (omnipotence) and God upheld goodness by not saving the baby (omnibenevolence).... One argument he anticipates immediately is that the child will be rewarded in heaven; however, if suffering was not truly necessary, then why allow it?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us