StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Desire to have Children - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
A married couple, Mary Sue and Junior Davis, unsuccessfully tried five times to have children. Each of those five attempts resulted in a tubal pregnancy, necessitating the need to terminate the pregnancy…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Desire to have Children
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Desire to have Children"

Download file to see previous pages

Finally, they decided to attempt in vitro fertilization. Mary Sue supplied nine eggs for the procedure, and her husband supplied sperm, which medical experts used to fertilize all the nine eggs in a laboratory. The medical personnel implanted two eggs in Mary Sue’s womb, but pregnancy did not result. The medical personnel froze the remaining seven fertilized eggs in order to preserve them for future use. Sometime later, the couple divorced, but they disagreed on who between them should claim the fertilized eggs and to what use they should be put.

Mar Sue claimed ownership of the fertilized eggs and expressed the desire to have them implanted in her body. Junior opposed Mary Sue’s claim of ownership and intention to implant the eggs. Instead, he wanted them destroyed. Mary Sue filed a law suit in court regarding the case. The judge ruled in her favor and granted her temporary custody of the fertilized eggs, so as to avail Mary Sue the chance to achieve a normal pregnancy by having medical experts implant the eggs in her womb. The rationale of this decision was that human life begins at conception and, therefore, the fertilized eggs were persons who have the right to the provision of suitable conditions and support that would allow them to develop into normal human beings.

The judge added that the final custody of the child, child support, and visitation would be decided by the same court if one of the eggs results in birth. II. Ethical Question to be Answered Was Judge W. Dale Young morally justified in regarding the fertilized eggs as persons that have a right to life and not as property? III. Proposed Answers to Ethical Question Judge Young’s decision was not morally justified because the frozen fertilized eggs were not naturally conceived and, therefore, this argument does not parallel the ones put forward by opponents of abortion.

It is appropriate to regard the fertilized eggs as property because medical experts created them artificially and, therefore, are the creation of human beings. In addition, the fertilized eggs do not have a societal, moral responsibility and; thus, they cannot be regarded as persons. A person has a moral role to play in society, the fertilized eggs do not. IV. Objections to Proposed Answers and Responses to the Objections Objection (1): The conceptus is a living human being because the continuous process of growth and development of human beings begins at conception.

Therefore, the frozen fertilized eggs should be regarded as conceptus since they came into existence as a result of conception. Whether conception takes place in a woman’s body or scientists induce it artificially in the laboratory, fact is it leads to the creation of a human life form, the zygote. Response (1): The conceptus does not have any of the functions of a human being and, therefore, cannot be bestowed with the same status as a human being living in the real world. Fertilized eggs are just a mass of cells which scientists or medical experts keep alive through artificial means, without whose assistance they will surely die.

A zygote that medical experts create and preserve through an artificially regulated process is not a real form of human life. This is because it is not supported or sustained in any way by the life processes that manifest themselves through nature. The same way that a graft of skin cells obtained from a person represents a living part of that person, it cannot be regarded as a person because they lack any of the moral functions associated with a person. Objection (2): God imparts a soul onto human beings at conception and not at birth since birth is just a transition from the womb into the world.

The life of the baby did not begin at birth, but it was alive from the moment of conception. Since every human

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Desire to have Children Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Desire to have Children Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1461505-davis-case
(Desire to Have Children Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Desire to Have Children Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1461505-davis-case.
“Desire to Have Children Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1461505-davis-case.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Desire to have Children

Child Care in Colleges are Essential

Many young women usually Desire to have Children in their early twenties, and there is scientific proof that this could b the time that women expose their children and themselves to the least health risk by having children then (Anderson and Dektar 4-5).... Running Head: Child Care in Colleges is Essential Name Name of instructor Date Child Care in Colleges is Essential College students that have children should have accessibility for child care on college campuses while they are attending classes....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Convincing that the same sex adoption morally wrong

Therefore, it is their right to have children born of their own flesh and blood, even if they were the result of a surrogate mother or the sperm of a man unknown to the child's mothers.... They believe, that they can best represent that interest as the normal families seem to have a hard time providing such for their children and adopted children.... Same sex couples claim that the high rate of divorce among the heterosexual couples makes them a bad example for the children who are traumatized by what could often times turn out to be messy divorces that put the child in the middle of an ugly custody battle....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Same Sex Marriage in India and the United States

In the US, same sex families claim to provide the same environment to the children and the children grow up in a better environment than natural families and hence through adoption, they can fulfill the Desire to have Children.... This essay compares the issues of the same sex marriage in India and the US....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

MLA style / the future of marriage

Some of them fear the influences two gay parents might have on children they may either have or adopt, and they also fear how this may affect the morals and values of society.... Those for gay marriage state that scientific studies have not established any factual evidence that gay couples actually are bad influences on the children they raise.... On the other hand, those who are for gay marriage also have solid arguments, like Schiffren.... Furthermore, they feel that those in love should have the opportunity to legalize their love, and also allow them to take advantage of things like tax breaks....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Bowlby's Viewpoint Concerning a Parent-Child Bond

I believe, at some time in their lives, human beings Desire to have Children who grow up to be healthy, happy and independent.... Although the load lightens as the children become older, they still require lots of time and attention if they are to prosper.... Giving time and attention to children requires ones to sacrifice other interests and activities (Bowlby 2).... From different studies, the author attests that healthy, happy and independent young adults and adolescents are products of stable homes in which both parents give enough time and attention to the children....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Living Together Before Marriage. A Good Idea

the paper will also explain the importance of staying together before marriage as a means of helping couples whose former relationships have been horrible and try and baby step them to overcome this past experience by staying together first.... Compatibility saves couples from messy and brutal divorce that they have to go through if their marriage is not working....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

A Legal Right to Terminate Pregnancy During the First Trimester

The choice is difficult because both decisions will have negative outcomes.... The paper "A Legal Right to Terminate Pregnancy During the First Trimester" focuses on the suffering of mother and child.... Every person chooses the best way according to his or her morality and situational context....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

HIV Positive Women Should Not Become Pregnant

Women infected with HIV may wish to avoid pregnancy or limit their family since they have reproductive patterns similar to HIV negative women.... Pregnancy in… Physicians and health care workers are faced with challenges while caring for pregnant women that have been diagnosed with HIV....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us