StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethical Dilemma in Nursing - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Ethical Dilemma in Nursing" presents nursing professionals that are increasingly facing legal/ethical dilemmas on a daily basis irrespective of the area or domain of their practice in healthcare environments. Their decisions must take into consideration laws and ethical standards…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Ethical Dilemma in Nursing"

The scenario revolved around a 21-year old woman who wanted to procure an abortion in a catholic-sponsored health institution.  Previous CT scans of the pregnancy had revealed that the baby would be born with a severe head deformity due to some drugs that the woman was advised to take during her fourth month of pregnancy.  The woman was in her seventh month of pregnancy, implying that the unborn baby could live if born prematurely.  The legal/ethical dilemma for the nursing professional revolved around guaranteeing that the patient’s rights were respected versus preserving the sanctity of life as elaborated in the Nurse Practice Act for the specific state as well as the American Nursing Association (ANA) code of ethics.

 Additionally, being a catholic-funded healthcare institution, the law was very clear that no abortion was to be procured for whatever reasons unless the life of either the mother or the unborn baby was at risk.   The woman had a right of choice to seek help in the termination of pregnancy as most states in the United States give legal power and authority to the person for what goes on in his or her body.  Indeed, available literature demonstrates that “protecting patients’ rights is part of the professional ethics of health care workers” (Yakov et al., 2010, p. 501).

 Yet, even if known ethical principles demand nurses to respect the decision making of the patient (autonomy) and also to bring about good for the patient (beneficence), the professionals are nevertheless obliged to follow the law or face penalties including termination of employment and license cancellation (Holm & Severinsson, 2014).  Components of the ANA code of ethics are clear that nursing professionals should do all that is in their reach to protect and preserve lives, including those of unborn babies (Loon, Vries, van der Weijden, Elwyn, & Widdershoven, 2014).

  This precisely illuminates the legal/ethical dilemma for the nursing professional who was requested by the patient to assist in terminating the pregnancy. Available literature demonstrates that “nurses must balance their decisions based on what evidence-based practices dictates, what the law mandates, and what the ethical dilemma calls for” (Loon et al., 2014, p. 541).  Drawing from this exposition, the legal/ethical dilemma was resolved by using effective communication skills and conflict resolution strategies to demonstrate to the patient that evidence-based practices have shown that children born with such defects have a high chance of survival.

 The patient was made to understand that it was for the best interests of her health and consciousness that the pregnancy was carried to term.  Overall, the request to assist in procuring the abortion was turned down as the nursing profession was well aware of the fact that violating components of the ANA code of ethics as well as parts of the Nurse Practice Act could result in employment and licensure penalties.  As already mentioned, the ethical principles involved in the scenario included beneficence and autonomy.

             Channels Used Effective communication is critical in resolving legal/ethical dilemmas as well as in ensuring adherence and satisfaction with care (O’Hagan et al., 2014).  In the case scenario, listening skills and the employment of positive emotions were used to ensure effective communication between the nursing professional and the patient.  These skills enabled the establishment of rapport- and relationship-building in the communication process, which in turn facilitated a quick understanding of the issues that revolved around the legal/ethical dilemma.

An interest-based conflict resolution strategy was used to resolve the dilemma.  Available literature demonstrates that “interest-based conflict resolution is designed to help people develop win-win solutions using creative and collaborative strategies to satisfy their mutual needs and interests, rather than competing with one another” (Barsky, 2010, p. 164-165).  Interprofessional collaboration was done between relevant stakeholders (nursing professionals, counselors, and physicians) to ensure that the legal/ethical dilemma was resolved from a multi-departmental perspective.

 Lastly, clear expectations were set to ensure that team members (nursing professionals, counselors, physicians, and patients) developed a constancy of purpose and foresight in the resolution of the legal/ethical dilemma. Conclusion This paper has illuminated an issue involving a pro-choice versus pro-life legal/ethical dilemma.  From the discussion, it is evident that nursing professionals encounter legal/ethical dilemmas on a daily basis and hence must develop effective strategies for use in resolving the issues and avoiding costly litigation or loss of employment.

 It is also evident that these professionals must be guided by professional codes of ethical conduct in resolving the dilemmas.  Of critical importance is the evaluation of evidence-based practices in ensuring that the decisions reached by parties guarantee the safety of the patient and at the same time shield nurses from employment and licensure penalties.                                

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Pro-Choice versus Pro-Life Legal/Ethical Dilemma in Nursing Essay, n.d.)
Pro-Choice versus Pro-Life Legal/Ethical Dilemma in Nursing Essay. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1893702-pro-choice-versus-pro-life-legal-ethical-dilemma
(Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Legal/Ethical Dilemma in Nursing Essay)
Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Legal/Ethical Dilemma in Nursing Essay. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1893702-pro-choice-versus-pro-life-legal-ethical-dilemma.
“Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Legal/Ethical Dilemma in Nursing Essay”. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1893702-pro-choice-versus-pro-life-legal-ethical-dilemma.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Dilemma in Nursing

Nursing Practice Standards and Ethics

hellip; It is particularly the case in medical department, where the nurses have to combat with the conflict between the job responsibilities and the call of conscience while experiencing ethical dilemma.... It is particularly the case in medical department, where the nurses have to combat with the conflict between the job responsibilities and the call of conscience while experiencing ethical dilemma.... Since Deborah is working as nursing practitioner at a private hospital, she forgets the very reality that private clinics and medical centers keep profit motif in priority while offering their services and pecuniary gains are of vital interest for them....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Nursing Perspective

The case study "nursing Perspective" primarily deals with the ethical perspective of nursing where a nurse is taking caring of a 26 week old infant, who is on a ventilator in a critical condition.... Case Study OfNursing perspectiveAbstract The case study primarily deals with the ethical perspective of nursing where a nurse is taking caring of a 26 week old infant, who is on a ventilator in a critical condition.... But, looking from the nursing perspective, there are various nursing considerations and legal aspects that need to be identified so that issue can be resolved efficiently, within the parameters of ethically correct actions....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Using web based research, find an environmental-based ethical dilemma from the past five years online

One proposed low emission solution is the construction of the Severn Barrage; Running Head: ENVIRONMENTAL ethical dilemma The Severn Barrage: An Environmental ethical dilemma The Severn Barrage: An Environmental Ethical DilemmaThe electric power generation sector is the second biggest contributor to the release of greenhouse gases in the environment contributing to a large part of the world's total emission of Carbon dioxide and methane....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Discussion Question

ethical dilemma shows a clash in the ideals of laws and personal interest.... In the case of the five people in the provided situation, their ethical dilemma is… They will risk their lives if ever they help those people amidst the burning hospital. 2.... Most people may say that life is precious and it should be protected at all cost, but the situation calls for a possible life Answers to Ethics Case Study: To Rescue Others at What Risk ethical dilemma shows a clash in the ideals of laws and personal interest....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Ethically Bound and Legally Speaking -Discussion

I am among the many nurses that have been confronted with an ethical dilemma in the… One day, an accident victim was rushed to the hospital.... I am among the many nurses that have been confronted with an ethical dilemma in the delivery of care to patients.... The patient who refuses nursing care.... The art of nursing: A practical introduction.... However, more than often, nurses are confronted with issues that pose ethical dilemmas that they have to deal with (Cooper, 2001)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us