StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Effects of Cultural and Linguistic Assimilation - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "The Effects of Cultural and Linguistic Assimilation" focuses on cultural and linguistic assimilation into a different community that contains within it prospects for both personal and moral growth, but also isolation and alienation from one’s original community. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
The Effects of Cultural and Linguistic Assimilation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Effects of Cultural and Linguistic Assimilation"

Cultural and linguistic assimilation into a different community contains within it prospects for both personal and moral growth, but also isolation and alienation from one’s original community. It allows for personal growth by allowing the creation of opportunities and rights not available through any other means. And it allows for isolation and alienation when the distinction between public and private life falls apart, and full individuality is lost in both realms. Nowhere is this clearer than in Richard Rodriguez’s piece “Aria”, in which he describes the “bilingualism” (as in those who believe that teaching young children two languages is necessary) that ultimately changed the structure of his original community.

To Rodriguez, his original community of Spanish was a private one, which he could speak in the home. In contrast, Spanish to Los gringos is just another public language, and to Rodriguez, the language of Los gringos would be the same. In the end, although his assimilation into the English community changed his prospects for Americanized success (or public gain), the household “[he] returned to each afternoon was quiet. Intimate sounds no longer rushed to the door to greet me… Once I learned the public language, it would never again be easy for me to hear intimate family voices”.

And therein lies the factor of alienation that the assimilation caused for the narrator, standing in stark contrast with the obvious benefits of being “Americanized” in the “American nation”.In Bich Minh Nguyen’s piece “The Good Immigrant Student”, the narrator recounts the story of a youth spent trying to assimilate into a different cultural community, initially struggling with the language. Moving to Grand Rapids, which is affectionately called “An All-American City”, she recounts that her sister and her “were Americanized as soon as [they] turned on the television”.

By telling us this, she deemphasizes the lasting effect of a bilingual education, which, like Rodriguez, does not believe ultimately is the primary factor in assimilation into a different cultural/linguistic community. She says, “Today, bilingual education is supposed to have become both a method of assimilation and a method of preservation, an effort to prove that kids can have it both ways. They can supposedly keep English for school and their friends and keep another language for home and family.

” These things the narrator finds impossible in conjunction. And therein lie the potential harms of a cultural and linguistic transformation of a young child, trying to survive through these formative years. Ultimately, the distinction that “bilingualism” makes between a public life (that of school and friends) and private life (that of home and family) will break down. The narrator of Nguyen’s story recounts her stepmother’s fear that learning English will take over wholly and push the Vietnamese out of their heads.

This, of course, is impractical. However, what is not impractical is that, culturally, assimilation will deemphasize the importance of one community as the other becomes important, and values from one community will be lost in favor of the values of the other, newer community. If this is the case, then it is certainly possible that linguistic and cultural alienation from one’s family and household will result. Younger children, in particular, might also find the process of assimilation difficult to deal with, which is different from the effects of the assimilation itself.

Nguyen recounts how terrified she was of reading English in front of the class. Asked to read louder, the young girl has trouble pronouncing words, which prompts other kids to tease her and chant unkind words. Although these taunts are painful, what to Nguyen might seem more painful is the sense of shame which accompanies her failure—her failure to be “invisible at that moment”. The end goal of her assimilation, at that moment, was to just disappear in the crowd. Rodriguez, talking about individuality and assimilation, mentions something along these lines: that separateness does not equate to individuality in the public realm.

In public, individuality is achieved by individuals who are members of the crowd, much like Nguyen’s narrator. In contrast, in private, individuality is a matter of separateness from the crowd, and a matter of connection “with intimates”. Rodriguez recounts how it was only when he was fully assimilated, or able to see himself not as a resident alien but as an American, could he seek “the rights… necessary for full public individuality”.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“In what specific ways can linguistic and/or cultural assimilation be Essay”, n.d.)
In what specific ways can linguistic and/or cultural assimilation be Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552360-in-what-specific-ways-can-linguistic-andor-cultural-assimilation-be-positive-effects-and-negatives-effects-how-can-assimilation-affect-an-individual-andor-a-family
(In What Specific Ways Can Linguistic and/Or Cultural Assimilation Be Essay)
In What Specific Ways Can Linguistic and/Or Cultural Assimilation Be Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552360-in-what-specific-ways-can-linguistic-andor-cultural-assimilation-be-positive-effects-and-negatives-effects-how-can-assimilation-affect-an-individual-andor-a-family.
“In What Specific Ways Can Linguistic and/Or Cultural Assimilation Be Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552360-in-what-specific-ways-can-linguistic-andor-cultural-assimilation-be-positive-effects-and-negatives-effects-how-can-assimilation-affect-an-individual-andor-a-family.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Effects of Cultural and Linguistic Assimilation

Language Learning, Bilingualism and Assimilation

The spoken or written word is today more appreciated that ever before especilly considering the effects of successful and unsuccessful negotiations.... Some quarters have argued that the learning of second languages has is associated with assimilation.... This paper will argue that the learning of a second language is not necessarily part of assimilation.... While some may acquire a new language during childhood by interacting with people who speak the second language, others learn by attending formal education (The linguistic Society of America 2)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

West African and African American Cultures - Before and After Emancipation

As the paper stresses, Africa had a great variety in cultural diversity, with various ethnic groups having their own cultural manifestations.... The purpose of this paper, West African and African American Cultures - Before and After Emancipation, is to investigate the relationship between the cultures of West Africans and African Americans as constructed and reconstructed before and after Emancipation....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Assimilation or Acculturation

These are the actual powers that eliminate 'physical boundaries' aggravate cultural and nationwide conflicts, bringing forth disturbing news features and a troubling politically based scenario.... This paper "assimilation or Acculturation" discusses the identity of a human being that is truly important.... It may come in an assorted flavoring but beneath it all, it is 'the dilemma of assimilation vs acculturation'.... No one can survive without his/her identity and to accept people as to whom they are and from the places, they belong and add them to one's own societal and cultural beliefs....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Linguistic Barriers to Cultural Assimilation in the United States

This research article 'Linguistic Barriers to Cultural assimilation in the United States' discusses the levels of linguistic acculturation and the difficulties non-native Arabic speakers will encounter by virtue of being in the United States or Saudi Arabia.... The hypothesis of this study is interlanguage-linguistic relativity determines cultural assimilation of Muslim women studying in the U.... When attending the United States University program, international students undergo some extreme cultural isolation that inhibits their ability to perform within the scholastic society....
10 Pages (2500 words) Article

Technology and Learning in the United Arab Emirates

The paper "Technology and Learning in the United Arab Emirates" highlights that selection of conventional learning practices is convolutedly tied to the establishment of an online educational environment needs an examination of socio-cultural issues that might present cultural obstacles....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

The Challenge of Intercultural Language Teaching

Varieties of linguistic objects develop found in the society that the language exists.... This literature review "The Challenge of Intercultural Language Teaching" demonstrated that language teachers should embrace the difference within different cultures and emphasize the unity among the cultures....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

Linguistic and Cultural Issues in Translation

The paper "linguistic and Сultural Issues in Translation" is a great example of a report on education.... The paper "linguistic and Сultural Issues in Translation" is a great example of a report on education.... hen tackling the issue of linguistic issues in translation, it is important to consider the various sub-fields of linguistics.... n morphology, there are morphemes; which are the smallest linguistic units that have meaning....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Language Planning in Education

Language change is a result of either natural processes of linguistic orientation or deliberate language planning.... The paper 'Lаnguаgе Рlаnning in Еduсаtiоn' seeks to explain the primary differences between language change and language planning in light of education.... Language is as old as the existence of man, language is the factor that holds people together and establishes all social relationships among people....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us