StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Welfare Reform - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
As the United States continues to reel from the after effects of the 2008 George W. Bush mishandling of our economy, our government finds itself in the unenviable position of having to find the balance between fiscal responsibility and caring for its citizens in need…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Welfare Reform
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Welfare Reform"

?Welfare Reform As the United s continues to reel from the after effects of the 2008 George W. Bush mishandling of our economy, our government finds itself in the unenviable position of having to find the balance between fiscal responsibility and caring for its citizens in need. For most of our jobless countrymen, welfare checks provide the means to continue to purchase life giving food as sustenance in their daily lives. However, the economic hardships that have befallen our local governments have forced its leaders to rethink and reform the local welfare laws in order to protect the neediest and deserving members of the state. This was done by multiple states in the guise of requiring all welfare participants to submit themselves to individual drug testing prior to their application for welfare. Although there have been some people caught as being positive for substance abuse in the past, this particular welfare reform has not been as successful as its implementing bodies hoped it would be. The failure of the drug testing law in relation to welfare privileges stem from the various complaints filed by different sectors of society against the law. These groups, such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) claim that the local law revisions are a violation of basic human rights and must therefore be declared null and void by the state courts. This paper aims to look into the validity of the legality of the claims by the various human rights organizations in an effort to prove the ill effectiveness of this particular law in relation to welfare reform. In order to understand the controversy surrounding the drug testing amendment to the local welfare laws, we have to look back 20 years in time, to the year 1996 when the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 was first implemented under the federal welfare reform law. According to the law those who wish to avail of the Family Independence Agency assistance need to provide urine samples in order to continue receiving government welfare (Watson, D. 1999). This move was vehemently opposed by the ACLU in the local Michigan courts as the group reasoned that the law is a blatant violation of the Fourth Amendment. Kary Moss, the representative of ACLU Michigan at the time explained that (1999): The Fourth Amendment guarantees that no individual in this country can be subjected to a search by the government unless there is reasonable suspicion that they have committed some crime, Welfare recipients may be poor, but that's not a crime—not yet, anyway. The ACLU believes that by requiring mandatory drug testing for welfare recipients, those wishing to avail of the government aid will have been branded by society in a negative manner before they have even been proven to have committed any offenses. The law simply has too many loop holes, in the opinion of the group, for it to become actually effective in preventing the use of tax payer dollars by drug addicts who happen to be a member of our society. In Michigan, they believed that this law would have been an effective deterrent towards drug abuse even though (1999): ... evidence from a 1996 federal study showing that "the percentage of welfare recipients using, abusing, or dependent on alcohol or drugs [is] relatively small and consistent with the general U.S. population and those not receiving welfare benefits... Due to the existing inconsistencies in the law, its implementation, and questionable effectiveness in deterring welfare recipients from participating in illegal drug activities, the law was eventually halted and has not been implemented since. Let us be clear though that this law has not become as widespread in implementation as the government had first hoped. This is because the 1996 Welfare Reform Act did not make it a mandatory prerequisite to receiving government aid. The ACLU claims that (ACLU, 2008): Before the Michigan policy was halted, only 10% of recipients tested positive for illicit drugs. Only 3% tested positive for hard drugs, such as cocaine and amphetamines – rates that are in line with the drug use rates of the general population. Since the failure of the drug testing portion of the 1996 Welfare reform Act, there has been a steady decline in the interest of other members of the United States in implementing that particular portion of the law. As such, the law has actually been repealed in a number of U.S. states ever since. One of the states where the ACLU was able to get the federal courts to successfully block the law was in Florida even though; “Florida became the first state to pass and fully implement a bill mandating suspicionless drug testing of all applicants for Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF).” (Bloom R., 2012). The courts declared the law unconstitutional based partly on the fact that the welfare applicant, who already has tight financial resources as it is, otherwise he would not be applying for a federal welfare check, was being required to personally pay for the mandatory drug testing in order to prove that he qualified for the grant with the possibility of a reimbursement in the event of a negative result. The ACLU was able to prove their case in the Florida courts as the verifiable statistics pertaining to the ill effectiveness of the drug testing law came back to support their claims. Results showed that (2006): In the four months that Florida's law was in place, the state drug tested 4,086 TANF applicants. A mere 108 individuals tested positive. To put it another way, only 2.6 percent of applicants tested positive for illegal drugs — a rate more than three times lower than the 8.13 percent of all Floridians, age 12 and up, estimated by the federal government to use illegal drugs. This argument was a triumph for the Florida branch of the ACLU as they successfully showed that Gov. Rick Perry was wrong when he claimed that this law was “compassionate”. There is nothing compassionate about a law that would block those in the most need of financial assistance from receiving government aid. Rather, it is a death sentence for the innocent people who could be victims of mislabeled and mishandled testing procedures in the testing centers. The penalty for a positive drug test is a year- long ban on receiving any welfare benefits from the state (DePrang, E., 2012.). Although the constitutionality of this law continues to be questioned in state courts and its implementation remains contaminated by controversy, there have been a total of 25 states this year alone that have proceeded to implement the law. The most recent of which is the state of Georgia under the leadership of Gov. Nathan Deal (Bloom, R. 2012). Even though there is a large majority of the general public that supports the 1996 Welfare Reform Act mandating the implementation of drug testing on welfare recipients, it is important to note that they do so merely on the basis of the government campaign to gain support for the program. Since taxpayer dollars are at the center of the heated debate on the constitutionality of the law, the tendency of the general public is to support any move that will help their state save on tax dollar expenses. In the minds of the American public, the discussion does not have anything to do with the legalities and constitutionality of the issue. Rather, they look at the matter based upon the economic effect that the implementation of the program will have upon them. If it saves the state and local government money, then they are all for the law, regardless of the questions surrounding it. The public supports the unconstitutional law because they do not have a full understanding of drug addiction as an illness. Politicians like governors Perry and Deal managed to gain support for the implementation of the law because they got their supporters to believe that drug addiction is a problem of the society instead of a psychological illness. As long as the ACLU and similar organizations continue to fight the implementation of the unconstitutional law, there will always be a great chance that the people who rely on the TANF for the support of their families will be able to get access to the much needed help. It would be a lot more helpful for everyone concerned though, if the drug testing portion of the 1996 Welfare Reform Law were repealed by a constitutional move instead. In the meantime, state repeals of the law such as the one that happened in Colorado (Hoover, T. 2012), which happened when the law died in the Colorado house upon 2nd reading serves as a beacon of hope that the law just may be killed in the future. Sources Bloom, R. (2012, 18 April). “Just as we suspected: Florida saved nothing by drug testing welfare applicants” [Web log comment]. Retrieved from http://www.aclu.org/blog/criminal-law-reform-racial-justice/just-we-suspected-florida-saved-nothing-drug-testing-welfare DePrang, E. (2012, Nov. 15). “Rick Perry’s 'compassionate' sales pitch for drug-testing welfare recipients.” Observer. Retrieved from http://www.texasobserver.org/rick-perrys-compassionate-sales-pitch-for-drug-testing-welfare-recipients/ Hoover, T. (2012, Mar. 9). “Bill to drug test welfare recipients dies in Colorado house second reading.” denverpost.com. Retrieved from http://www.denverpost.com/breakingnews/ci_20283105/drug-test-welfare-bill-dies-colorado-house-second N.A. (2008). “Drug testing of public assistance recipients as a condition of eligibility.” Safe Communities, Fair Sentences. Retrieved from http://www.aclu.org/drug-law- reform/drug-testing-public-assistance-recipients-condition-eligibility Watson, D. (1999). “Michigan begins random drug testing of welfare recipients”. World Socialist Website. Retrieved from http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/1999/11/drug-n09.html Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Welfare Reform Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1464891-welfare-reform
(Welfare Reform Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1464891-welfare-reform.
“Welfare Reform Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1464891-welfare-reform.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Welfare Reform

Welfare Reform Affects Us All

Throughout modern history there have been many social programs aimed at helping poor people, especially in difficult times… Welfare Reform Affects Us All Welfare programs, no matter how one looks at the situation, adversely affect us all.... What actually happened during the Welfare Reform was simply amazing.... welfare programs, no matter how one looks at the situation, adversely affect us all.... So much so that in 1994, the welfare, Food Stamps, and Medicaid programs comprised 20% of the national budget....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Research Proposal on: Effects of Welfare Reform

These… Since many are so dependent on these services it is important to consider the effects that Welfare Reform will have on those needing the assistance and those paying for Research Proposal Effects of Welfare Reform The effects of Welfare Reform are great for many individuals whom are dependent on the welfare system.... Since many are so dependent on these services it is important to consider the effects that Welfare Reform will have on those needing the assistance and those paying for the assistance....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

The Effects Of Welfare Reform

Running Head: Effects of Welfare Reform Effects of Welfare Reform: A Reflective Paper Antonio Glenn English Composition II Katherine Nelson-Born Effects of Welfare Reform Welfare is a phenomenon which is unanimously supported by religion, morality, social ethics and culture.... Running Head: Effects of Welfare Reform Effects of Welfare Reform: A Reflective Paper Antonio Glenn English Composition II Katherine Nelson-Born Effects of Welfare Reform Welfare is a phenomenon which is unanimously supported by religion, morality, social ethics and culture....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Effects of Welfare Reform

Never-mind the issue of Welfare Reform itself, the very issue or policy are of welfare or social assistance is a highly contentious and divisive one.... Therefore, the issue itself is 'economic' and not 'ideological', and this means that the divisions that exist on Welfare Reform are meaningless.... Thus, during the 1990's, Welfare Reform was driven by reducing taxes, reducing governme... Further, it will be demonstrated in this analysis that in spite of a long history of welfare-reform, current levels of social assistance payment in the State of Georgia are barely sufficient for just subsistence....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Child Welfare Reform

“Child Welfare Reform: Will the Recent Changes Make at Risk Children Safer?... Price, the author of the article questions the effectiveness of the United States Child welfare program in protecting children against abuse from both biological and adopting parents.... hellip; To demonstrate the ineffectiveness of the Child welfare program, the author contends that 16 states in the country did not fulfill any of the seven federal childcare standards used to evaluate the efficiency of the program in the previous year....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Welfare Reform in the US

The author of the essay states that to save the government money, to decrease the amount of money fueling drug addictions, and to help people who really could use the financial assistance, drug testing should become a requirement for applying for welfare.... hellip; The primary response to the concept that drug testing for welfare goes against the Fourth Amendment is that if people have to undergo mandatory drug testing to apply for most jobs, they should have to undergo drug testing to receive welfare....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

UK Welfare Reform Bill

This essay "UK Welfare Reform Bill" is about the bill which introduces a number of changes to the already existing social welfare laws.... nbsp;It was aimed at streamlining the UK social welfare in order to make it more effective and efficient.... The UK Department of welfare and Pensions has refuted any claims of workfare increasing the likelihood to find work....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Welfare Reform Affects Us All

This paper ''Welfare Reform Affects Us All'' tells that Welfare programs, no matter how one looks at the situation, adversely affect us all.... What happened during the Welfare Reform was simply amazing.... nbsp; Its goals were to:1) end welfare as an entitlement program, 2) require recipients to secure employment after two years on the system, 3) place a lifetime limit of five years on government assistance programs, 4) support two-parent families and discourage illegitimate births, and 5) enhance child support enforcement....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us