StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Planning thoery - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
Both Alexander and Darke deal with rationality and a number of concepts relating to it. There are a number of similarities between the two articles. They start off by isolating the idea of rationality so that a brief definition is established. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Planning thoery
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Planning thoery"

Both Alexander and Darke deal with rationality and a number of concepts relating to it. There are a number of similarities between the two articles.They start off by isolating the idea of rationality so that a brief definition is established. The historical definition is taken into consideration and its various pitfalls examined. The rejection of ideas and resulting theories that evolved as a result of experiences and information collected through the senses is noted. Rather, theories that resulted from information gathering and analysis through mathematical methods were adopted.

However, in doing so, the manipulation of the system to achieve certain desired objectives has been the effect. This has been demonstrated to be one of the traditional methods. In addition, the idea that a universally relevant and applicable value system of rationality has been refuted by both the authors through several illustrations time and again. However, Alexander (2000, p. 243) notes that there is merit even in the pursuit of such a universal system even if it is non - existent since it adds perspective and value to the debate.

Rationality is further explored as a multidimensional subject with respect to values, goals, beliefs and finally the intended action required in a certain scenario. The importance of formal and substantive rationality is established in both works (Darke, 1985, p. 16-18) however, Alexander (2000, p. 247-249) goes on to deal with a number of other types of the phenomena. For example, communicative rationality is discussed, as the interaction between the various subjects and processes of a fair communication process in a given scenario.

Hence, the underlying assumptions and beliefs of various types of rationalities are dealt in greater detail by Alexander. Finally, each of the articles moves onto its area of specialization, namely rationality planning in the first case whereas in the second case, rationality is applied to the case of state programs. However, in both the cases, the negative effects of the application of a single definition of rationality are detailed. While the multidimensional approach of Alexander leads to more questions than answers, the application of rationality to the field of state run programs by Darke explores the various mistakes committed in the past.

Hence, it is essentially a suggestion for the future of such programs in which a more encompassing definition of the phenomena would prove beneficial. However, the work of both the authors approaches a common theme that of the need to consider a number of factors such as beliefs, experience, values in addition to the factors affecting the scenario at hand while applying rationality to planning. The application of rationality to real world problems encompassing such a multitude of factors necessitates the simplification of the models.

The processes involved in the decision making process for real world challenges are dealt with by Lindblom. He outlines the fundamental differences to different models of decision making in the real world and also lists the differences in theory and practice (1959, 81). In his own words, he also attempts to provide theoretical support to the methods most commonly used to solve complex real world problems. By dealing with the theoretical considerations of the decision making process, the author has been able to identify a number of implementation issues.

This compliments the work of Darke (1985, p. 23-24) rather than Alexander who deals with the various aspects concerning rationality planning. Rationality planning is only one of the issues that Lindblom deals with although it is not mentioned explicitly. While the study of the first two articles gives the impression that rationality has a number of dimensions and that it is important to apply a certain aspect or type of rationality depending on the situation, the third article stresses the fact that practical situations usually revert to iterations of previous decisions rather than the formation of a decision based on pure theory.

Therefore, it is represented as an iterative process and goes on to conclude that it is the only possible and practical solution to complex practical issues. However, each of the articles has value in its own right and it is hard to compare one with the other without considering the factors against which they are measured. With respect to knowledge of rational planning and decision making, it could be concluded that a study of all three articles provides comprehensive knowledge to the reader since the issues covered in the articles are complementary as they provide theoretical and practical foundations of the topic.

Works Cited Alexander, Ernest R. “Rationality Revisited: Planning Paradigms in a Post-Postmodernist Perspective.” Journal of Planning Education and Research. vol. 19. issue 242. (2000): 242-256. Print. Darke, Roy (1985). Rational planning and the state. Rationality in planning. pp. 15-25. Print Lindblom, Charles. E. “The Science of Muddling Through.” Public Administration Review. Vol. 19. No. 2 (1959), pp 79-88.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Planning thoery Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1410913-planning-thoery
(Planning Thoery Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1410913-planning-thoery.
“Planning Thoery Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1410913-planning-thoery.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Planning thoery

Theory and Practice of Strategic Planning for Tourism

Strategic planning in Tourism and Leisure: A Critical Assessment of the Theory and Practice of Strategic planning for Tourism 1.... There are numerous approaches to tourism planning as stated by Getz (1986) are boosterism, economic, physical / spatial, community....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

Regional Planning Theory of Patrick Geddes

It is also in this same time frame when he started to concentrate on planning ideas/concepts.... P CLOSE: IDEAS THAT CHANGED THE WORLDREGIONAL planning Regional planning is the effective program of land use activities, infrastructure and settlement expansion over an individual city or town area.... It is therefore a process of planning for the improvement of urban areas, residential settlements, positioning of economic/trade centers, leisure and aesthetic areas that will more or less assure the safety, health and physical consideration of the dwellers....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Challenges for Planning Theory

Critically discuss the view that challenges for planning theory are concerned with new and re-theorisations of uncertainty, conflict and political complexities, not much about what planning theory is about but what it can do. ... lanning can be defined as “the methods used by… Spatial planning includes all levels of land use planning including urban planning, regional planning, environmental planning, national spatial plans and in the European Union Thus spatial planning is regarded as a wider approach and this report would basically focus its attention on spatial planning in urban areas and also the regulations and policies which can directly impact on urban renewal....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Boosterism in Tourism Planning

Boosterism is still an essential feature of tourism planning because it ensures that a large number of places which would not have been recognized get a chance to be toured.... Therefore, while boosterism is sometimes seen in a negative light, it is an essential part of tourism planning because it brings previously obscure areas into the limelight.... Furthermore, this type of promotion makes possible the development of effective planning to ensure that the security of tourists is guaranteed under all circumstances (Dredge and Jenkins, 2006, 29)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Bad Planning Theory

This work called "Bad planning Theory" focuses on the problem of bad planning in parts of Abu Dhabi.... nbsp;… The physicalists were bound to their own conception of town planning and the planners tended to see the towns and their issues in aesthetic terms.... They did not pay attention to social matters because their theory of planning obstructed them from considering social issues.... The origin of the problem is attributed to the surveys that were undertaken by the town planners in preparation for planning, they were rarely done....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Categories of Planning Theory

"Categories of planning Theory" paper examines rational –comprehensive planning theory, advocacy planning theory, incremental list planning theory, and the two branches of communicative planning theory: planning as consensus-seeking and management of conflicts.... The control of development through the granting and refusing of planning permission came to control position in the British planning system created in the early forty's....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Is Contemporary Planning Theory Responsive to Wrights Lessons

This line of thought was strongly supported by other planning analysts and experts such as David Brooks, Paul Fussell, and Sharon Zukin.... This kind of reasoning makes quite some sense because other planning experts have alluded to the fact that history (including human history) usually repeats itself; implying that a thorough analysis of historical events is key to providing solutions to today's challenges....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Urban Planning Theory and Decision Making

This term paper "Urban planning Theory and Decision Making" presents urban planning as both a political and technical process involved in the control of land use and urban environment design in a bid to guiding the evolvement of orderly settlements and communities in urban areas.... hellip; There are many theories that guide participants in urban planning.... As such, planning can be termed rational planning or democratic planning....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us