StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Nurturing Giftedness in Young Children Too Young for Gifted Programs Article - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Analysis of Nurturing Giftedness in Young Children Too Young for Gifted Programs Article" paper gives a response to the summary article entitled “Nurturing Giftedness in Young Children” and the article "Preschoolers Too Young for Gifted Programs" and gives his opinion regarded the issues…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Analysis of Nurturing Giftedness in Young Children Too Young for Gifted Programs Article
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Nurturing Giftedness in Young Children Too Young for Gifted Programs Article"

I agree with Roedell’s thesis that a child, gifted or not, should be treated as an individual. I believe that that is the fundamental idea of how to nurture children with their unique individuality and capacity for learning. Undoubtedly, treatment based on the individual’s individuality is essential. In analyzing Roedell’s argument, however, he fails to provide a prescriptive method on how to properly nurture children, especially the gifted ones.

I do not think that he offers anything new. Yes, I agree that developments among children are varied and different. Yes, I also agree that other children are fast learners while others are not. I could quote every line in Roedell’s article and say, “Yes, I agree with all of my heart.” It seems to me that Roedell merely states the facts but fails to offer any critical analysis. If Roedell made a critical analysis concerning what it means, or what are the ways, to treat a child as an individual, then Roedell could begin from there by offering a fresh perspective.

Response to the Summary Article entitled “Are Preschoolers Too Young for Gifted Programs?” I agree that all G/T programs offered in schools for gifted children should be promoted and fostered. However, I think that the child’s age before enrolling him or her into a G/T program should be a special concern for parents and the academe. The age of three, I believe, is not a good measure for allowing, or worst forcing, gifted children to study in a G/T program. That’s a very young age for a young child, gifted or not, to go to school.

A gifted child needs more than just intellectual stuff. He or she needs, among others, a social, physically-active, and emotional life. It also interests me why few schools offer G/T programs to affluent urban families. It implies, at least to my understanding, that G/T program is a money-making business for the learning institution. Moreover, it fascinates me why parents enroll their children in G/T programs. It sounds like they are doing it for the sake of prestige – namely, that their child is a “smart” kid.

My Answer to Question Number One. I think that tiered instruction is better than the traditional way of teaching. Tiered instruction is premised on the idea that individuals have different levels of learning ability and therefore require diverse teaching strategies. Different students are taught differently. For instance, a student who struggles to grasp abstract thinking will need a different treatment compared to an advanced student who learns easily. Although both of these students are taught in different ways, still the essential concept being taught is the same.

I think an enrichment program for gifted children is too much. Before academic professionals provide these children with a sort of enrichment, they should first consider the fact that these children are individuals with individual needs. I think that it is difficult to measure the acceleration phase of a child. IQ has flaws. Concerned academics should focus more on the interest and personality of the gifted child, and not on the intelligence purely based on his or her age level. My Answer to Question Number Four.

I think that gifted students will benefit from an educational system that promotes a learning environment that caters to “an inch wide and a mile deep.” The principle of establishing learning institutions is for learners to learn. To learn means to gain relevant knowledge that would help students cope with life’s challenges. There are many ways for students to qualitatively learn. Certainly, teaching at “a mile wide” pace is not one of them. Mile-wide learning sharply contradicts the very foundation of education.

I fear that such a teaching process results in a type of learning that is “an inch deep.” Pragmatically, it’s useless to teach numerous topics to students if they merely learn a little. Assuming that students learn a lot from a mile-wide curriculum, still genuine learning won’t occur because they merely accumulate several pieces of information that do not make sense to their worldview. For learning to truly occur, students should be taught to think “a mile deep” in a manner of teaching that is just “an inch wide.”

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Response to the Summary Article entitled Nurturing Giftedness in Young Assignment”, n.d.)
Response to the Summary Article entitled Nurturing Giftedness in Young Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1568918-article-summary-response-and-discussion-question-response
(Response to the Summary Article Entitled Nurturing Giftedness in Young Assignment)
Response to the Summary Article Entitled Nurturing Giftedness in Young Assignment. https://studentshare.org/education/1568918-article-summary-response-and-discussion-question-response.
“Response to the Summary Article Entitled Nurturing Giftedness in Young Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1568918-article-summary-response-and-discussion-question-response.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Nurturing Giftedness in Young Children Too Young for Gifted Programs Article

Gifted Children: Annotated Bibliography

Another interesting area is the analysis of giftedness in various spheres of life ranging from music, literature, sport, and cinema.... This paper talks about gifted children.... gifted children are gifted with a better brain than other children are.... According to the report the scholarly world has been in dispute regarding the features of such gifted children, how to identify gifted children, how to handle them effectively, the neuropsychological factors behind being gifted, the way the gifted people observe the world, and the common socio-cultural issues faced by gifted children....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Gifted Young Children: A Guide for Teachers and Parents by Louise Porter

Likewise, the lack of interest at a particular school level is because the child finds it boring to achieve the same targets again and again as the child has already covered that level when he/she was too young for that.... This book review "Gifted young children: A Guide for Teachers and Parents by Louise Porter" sheds some light on the audience's attention towards the possibility of giftedness in children that generally display the signs of delayed development....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Exceptionally Gifted Children

This paper "Exceptionally gifted Children" tells that children with exceptional abilities possess the innate potential to live highly fulfilling lives and make important contributions to society.... Children labeled as 'gifted' languish in an educational system that does not satisfy their intellectual and creative needs and suffer socially as they are frequently misunderstood by parents and shunned or ignored by their peers.... gifted children may display a precocious rate of cognitive and intellectual growth....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Council for Exceptional Children

olorado Association for gifted and Talented (CAGT)This is a nonprofit organization (CAGT, 2011).... The main aim of the Colorado Association for gifted and Talented is to raise the understanding of gifted children as well as their exceptional needs.... he National Association for gifted Children (NAGC)This is an organization of teachers, parents, community leaders, and professionals who come together to help the youths and children with talents as well as gifts by addressing their unique needs (NAGC, 2008)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Giftedness in Education

t is imperative for institutions of learning to have unique strategies for gifted students.... The paper "giftedness in Education" is an outstanding example of an essay on education.... The paper "giftedness in Education" is an outstanding example of an essay on education.... Intellectual giftedness in childhood is understood as having advanced functioning in language and thinking.... The word "gifted" stimulates strong emotional reactions in the educational community, be they positive or negative....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

School and Emotional Development of Intellectually Gifted Children

The paper "School And Emotional Development Of Intellectually gifted Children" is a perfect example of a report on education.... Education of the intellectually gifted children has largely focused on their cognitive abilities.... The paper "School And Emotional Development Of Intellectually gifted Children" is a perfect example of a report on education.... Education of the intellectually gifted children has largely focused on their cognitive abilities....
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework

A New Gifted Education Program

The paper 'A New gifted Education Program' is a motivating variant of a term paper on education.... The paper 'A New gifted Education Program' is a motivating variant of a term paper on education.... This last category defines gifted students.... A student in the first year of study who is able to read or solve mathematics problems meant for Year 5 of study will be a gifted student (Johnsen, 2004).... gifted students are those with exceptional cognitive, creative, and affective abilities compared to their peers of the same age and growing in a similar environment (Schwean and Saklofske, 1999)....
19 Pages (4750 words) Term Paper

Supporting Diverse Gifted Students

ey messages/ issues or terminologyA key message of the article is that the 10 commandments can be translated into applicable practical applications in schools.... hree questions that the reading answersA key question that this article addresses related to the aptitude domains and they include creative, intellectual, socio-affective, and sensoriMotor.... It also defines the term vertical discrimination and based on the article it means to admit concentration levels within each gift and talent....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us