StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper will make an earnest attempt to explore the reasons illegal immigrants should receive social services. That the number of illegal immigrants in the US is rather high is supported by quite many studies and government statistics…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services"

Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services Introduction That the number of illegal immigrants in the US is rather high is supported by quite many studies and government statistics. For instance, in December 2012, the Pew Hispanic Center approximated the number of illegal immigrants in the U.S. in March 2011 as 11.1 million. On a rather positive note, this figure was a drop from the previous two years, a reported decline from its 2007 peak of 12 million illegal immigrants. Several reasons for this decline have been recorded, the first being the drop in the number of new immigrants from Mexico, which is undeniably the largest county of origin of illegal immigrants (Cull & Carrasco, p. 255). That the number of illegal immigrants is on the decline is supported by studies across the board.

However, the contentious issue about illegal immigrants is whether they should receive social services such as food stamps, welfare, and medical care or not (Borjas, p. 1335). This paper explores this issue, taking the stance that illegal immigrants should receive social services. Specifically, the socioeconomic benefits of illegal immigrants are cited as the reasons for this stance. The Reasons Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services The first aspect in which illegal immigrants benefit the country economically is through consumer demand.

That is, the economic activities undertaken by illegal immigrants’ spending offers employment to approximately 5% of the entire US workforce (Briggs, p. 193). In addition, illegal immigrants are tenants to quite a number of land and house owners in the country, thus providing income for these citizens. The other aspect in which illegal immigrants economically benefit the country and therefore ought to receive social services is in respect to employment. In fact, many employers really benefit from the illegal status of these immigrants.

For instance, employers exploit desperate illegal immigrants who are more than willing to accept poor pay and work in unhealthy conditions. Because of the employer-advantages associated with hiring illegal immigrants, employers pay less in non-wage costs and welfare contributions (Cull & Carrasco, p. 255). Hence, to compensate for this situation, illegal immigrants should enjoy social services such as food stamps, welfare, and medical care. Support for illegal immigrants is also based on the taxes they contribute towards the building of economy.

Unfortunately, most opponents argue that illegal immigrants do not pay taxes and that illegal immigrants consume more services than they contribute taxes. Nothing could be further from the truth. In the US, IRS (Internal Revenue Services) reports that approximately six million illegal immigrants file individual income tax returns annually (Cull & Carrasco, p. 255). The fact that illegal immigrants contribute towards the Social Security and Medicare directly to support older US citizens is the other ground on which they should be supported to enjoy social services.

The fact that illegal immigrants are not authorized to enjoy social security and Medicare services makes it humane that they be considered for other social services. In addition, the Internal Revenue Service issues people with Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers (ITIN) without considering their immigration status (Cull & Carrasco, p. 255). This ITIN issuance implies that both resident and nonresident aliens have Federal tax return and payment responsibilities under the Internal Revenue Code.

What is more, illegal immigrants also pay social security payroll taxes but are not entitled to be beneficiaries. It has also been reported that illegal immigrants pay more taxes than the same groups or people that want them ousted or denied social services. That is, illegal immigrants could be supporting social life in the US than some of those groups and individuals opposed to their access to the same services. Since they pay taxes and taxes are the foundation of social security, welfare, unemployment benefits, and Medicare, it is only logical that illegal immigrants enjoy these benefits (Briggs, p. 193). In these ways and others, illegal immigrants pay more to and support social services than they actually enjoy or receive from these services.

In essence, illegal immigrants pay taxes on social security, Medicare, and unemployment insurance while they are locked out of enjoying any of the benefits associated with these services. In other terms, illegal immigrants support a social welfare system they do not benefit from. Unlike wealthy US citizens who create debt for social services instead of increasing the net worth of social security, Medicare, and unemployment, illegal immigrants support the same social services (Briggs, p. 193).

Thus, illegal immigrants boost the net worth of the US social system via funding. Regrettably, they do not use the services or the money placed therein (Briggs, p. 193). From these arguments, it is clear that illegal immigrants fund the country’s social programs, thereby contributing the entire nation’s wellbeing. Instead of assisting them by making social services accessible to them, the country is constantly trying to get rid of illegal immigrants. Thus, as long as they are in the country, U.S. citizens and government should allow illegal immigrants to enjoy social services such as welfare, unemployment benefits, Medicare, and food stamps among others (Briggs, p. 193). Conclusion Whether illegal immigrants should receive social services continues to be a hotly debated issue in the immigration subject in the U.S. Several reasons support the assertion that illegal immigrants should enjoy such services.

These reasons are; illegal immigrants pay taxes, offer cheap labor, contribute to social services, and pay taxes on social security, Medicare, and unemployment insurance. Works Cited Borjas, G. The Labor Demand Curve is Downward Sloping: Reexamining the Impact of Immigration on the Labor Market, 2003. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(4): 1335. Briggs, V. M. The State of U.S. Immigration Policy: The Quandary of Economic Methodology and the Relevance of Economic Research to Know. 2009. Journal of Law, Economics and Policy, 5(1): 193. Cull, N. J.

, and Carrasco, D. Alambrista and the US-Mexico Border: Film, Music, and Stories of Undocumented Immigrants. 2004. University of New Mexico Press.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services Assignment - 3”, n.d.)
Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services Assignment - 3. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1622199-essay-3
(Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services Assignment - 3)
Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services Assignment - 3. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1622199-essay-3.
“Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services Assignment - 3”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1622199-essay-3.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Illegal Immigrants Should Receive Social Services

Illegal immigrants receiving social services, for example, food stamps, welfare, and medical care

The Federation for American Immigration Reform estimates about $45 billion worth of expenses for providing social services, education, roads, prisons and other services to these unauthorized immigrants (Glicken, p.... hellip; They become undocumented or unauthorized immigrants, also known as illegal immigrants.... It's difficult to get the accurate number of illegal immigrants because they conceal their status.... In contrast, studies that focus on illegal immigrants such as a paper published by the American Immigration Law Foundation indicate that unauthorized immigrants does not use public services as much as the legal immigrants (Wepman, p....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Immigrant Access to Health Insurance and Medical Care

Legal and illegal immigrants usually rely on a makeshift system of free hospitals and safety-net clinics, or even medical care at reduced prices, such as in the county and state owned facilities.... These illegal immigrants are not eligible for state funded benefits and find it more difficult to secure private insurance.... Since such a large number of immigrants do not have health care, they come up against serious barriers in pursuit of medical care and have to pay more from personal savings to receive care....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Literature review of Migrant Health

These issues are remarkably intense for immigrants to Europe, who have tremendously miniature rates of health insurance cover and inadequate health care services.... In spite the significant need for mental health services, migrants face considerable barriers to accessing adequate mental health care.... Nevertheless, immigrants have lower utilization, and minimal access to mental health care services.... Immigrants encounter numerous obstacles to receiving health care service, for example, they mistrust mental health professionals, and may also lack adequate finances for these services....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

The Rise of Unlawful Immigrants

Unlawful migrants unlike lawful migrants do not have access to social security, Medicare and other tested welfare services.... However their children benefit from highly subsidized public education, medical benefits and welfare services offered by the government.... These available resources get overburdened due to congestion effects hence leading to decline of quality of services to be offered to lawful migrants and non-immigrants.... Briefly describe what is in each category Government benefits and services are distributed into six categories as follows: Direct benefits - : This involves the cost of services offered to the citizens or the direct cash transfer....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Potential Problems with Illegal Immigration

The evidence demonstrates that benefits played an important role in unemployment and demands additional spending on social services for the unemployed population.... hellip; The author states that illegal immigrants become the main labor force in unskilled professions.... Wage stagnation is another problem caused by illegal immigrants in the USA.... Following Jacobe (2006): "the current wage stagnation is a cause of the influx of a huge number of illegal immigrants who violate the U....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

The Real Expense of Illegal Immigration

Approximately half of current illegal immigrants do not possess a high-school level education.... The researcher of the essay "The Real Expense of Illegal Immigration" aims to analyze how the massive numbers of illegal aliens pouring across mainly the southern border have and continues to cause substantial economic, social and physical harms to legal citizens.... Today, immigrant families are at least 50 percent more likely to receive federal benefits than those born in this country....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Proposal

Immigration Problems in the United States

The population comprises of both legal and illegal immigrants.... Debates abound on how the immigrants impact the US economy.... According to Fandl (2007), there are over nine million undocumented immigrants… There are almost 10 to 11 million illegal migrants who perform crucial jobs in the economy.... immigrants and low-skilled immigrant workers are concentrated in a few states and in those states, in a few metropolitan areas (Chiswick, 2006)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Illegal Immigration

Individuals who oppose illegal immigrants' presence in the United States argue that these individuals are a major social and economic burden on the United States economy.... hellip; Most studies that have attempted to determine the economic effects of illegal immigrants in the United States have concluded that the income collected by government agencies in the form of taxes both indirect taxes, illegal taxes and the authorized taxes, exceed the costs of the rendered services they receive, in the long run (Marceli and Heer 281)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us