StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Thomas Nagel's Moral Luck - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
Self-esteem as the image of the people, according to Kent, should be influenced neither by an individual’s actions nor by judgements. Self-judgment and action are the key aspects in which the id, ego and superego personalities revolve around…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Thomas Nagels Moral Luck
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Thomas Nagel's Moral Luck"

Download file to see previous pages

This makes a person’s action and judgement as the key elements of life. According to Nagel, good will represents an inner feeling exhibited by the people in their daily interaction systems (Nagel 1). Without the good will, the wished-for end of anyone is prone to be unsuccessful. Presumably, the good will enhances a wider-range of friendly relationships and the achieving of the end drives in life. The bad will, on the other hand, becomes a bit complicated in the determination of the people’s peaceful co-existence and their destinies (Nagel 1).

The bad will is normally inclined towards evil deeds. The evil deeds do not have a place in most societies. This, therefore, makes bad deeds be grouped under sanctions, which are punishable by the societal laws. The bad wills are against the norms of several social groups. People whose mindsets revolve around the bad will judgements and actions, in most cases, are normally viewed as the social misfits (Nagel 2). This, according to Nagel, is because the bad will paves way for a poor moral responsibility, which does not bring morally acceptable resolutions to many in the long-run (Nagel 1).

Nagel further argues that moral judgement and actions are the key elements where the most problems normally emanate from (Nagel 3). A problem experienced at an individual level normally affects behaviours positively. At the societal level, the problem experienced by one person will form a stable pattern thus affecting the completely social organization. Nagel believes that judgement differs from the evaluation of something good or bad morally (Nagel 3). The functional and dysfunctional elements of a moral judgement greatly differ.

This is because what is morally upright or functional for one person may be morally unstable or dysfunctional for another, in the determination of their luck. Control measures, which include both the positive and the negative sanctions, should be used for the conformity and compliance in the moral judgement of the individuals. This is because the moral judgement revolves around ignorance and the involuntary movements both in the external and the internal behavioural aspects exhibited by the individuals.

Not every action or moral judgement should rely on the goodwill or the bad will moral behaviours in order to find the social or behavioural changes solutions in the end luck. Moral judgement, according to Kant, has got the external influences either positively or negatively thus making the environment a key determinant of the individuals bad will or good will moral judgments (Nagel 3). The moral luck is not paradoxical. This is justified by Nagel in his book. This behavioural aspect can be compared to the theory of knowledge in philosophy.

In the theory of knowledge, there are various natural occurrences emerging just like the moral luck in people’s behaviour hence making them hard and challenging to understand (Nagel 6). Our beliefs, therefore, become the basis upon which these factors emerging from an individual’s behaviour can be understood. This, on the other hand, is because of the lack of the external social control mechanisms and the impracticality of encompassing these emerging issues without being at the mercy of others who are on the leading and influences our already questionable knowledge on the moral luck, judgments, actions and goodwill and bad will.

The ways in which the natural objects subjects individuals to moral luck include through the constitutive luck, which emanates from the personality. The other classification of luck includes one’s situations. The different situations and problems the individuals undergo calls for the different measures in their moral luck determination (Nagel 6)). Lastly, there are effects and causes of action and

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Thomas Nagel's Moral Luck Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1494067-thomas-nagel-s-moral-luck
(Thomas Nagel'S Moral Luck Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1494067-thomas-nagel-s-moral-luck.
“Thomas Nagel'S Moral Luck Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1494067-thomas-nagel-s-moral-luck.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Thomas Nagel's Moral Luck

Summary and opinion on each article

moral luck -- Thomas Nagel What you do is important; but how you do what you do is more important.... Thomas Nagel's “moral luck,” concerns the second part of this sentence.... Nagel discusses the issue of moral assessment.... Subject: Philosophy, Essay Date: Topic: Summary and Opinion on Each Article Myth of Sisyphus—Albert Camus The main problem with philosophers like Albert Camus is their reach is up to the level of their mind only....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Kant's Moral Philosophy

Objection The best objection to Kant's deontological ethics as formulated by categorical imperative is Thomas Nagel's argument about moral luck.... Unlike Kant, Thomas Nagel makes an exception through his assertion of moral luck that there are a broad range of externalities that affects moral judgment.... moral luck occurs when “an agent can be correctly treated as an object of moral judgment despite the fact that a significant aspect of what she is assessed for depends on factors beyond her control” (Nelkin, 2013)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Preview 5 Aquinas, An Anthology on Natural Law and Politics

Name Institution Course Instructor Date thomas Aquinas analysis about the humanity, happiness, and universe thomas Aquinas was a great philosopher and theologist, who differentiated philosophy and theology by vividly outlining the big difference between the two aspects.... The difference between the two aspects according to Saint thomas was that each aspect is a separate fountain of knowledge needed by human beings (Aquinas, 2003: 12)....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Fiction Writers of the New Millennium

The author examines the short stories "Entropy” by thomas Pynchon, “Lost in the Funhouse” by John Barth and DeLillo's “The Angel Esmeralda", and states that major writers are major because of the ability to adhere to and break the rules of fiction in order to present thought-provoking stories....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

The Absurd by Thomas Nagel

?moral Soundings: Readings on the Crisis of Values in Contemporary Life.... Hence nagel's argument was totally justified.... In addition, he says that the seriousness of people towards their life is The Absurd thomas Nagel is a well known philosopher and extremely popular for this exceptional evaluation on the reductionist description of the mind.... Conversely, thomas Nagel here criticized that the actual absurd roots from the two martial propensities....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Comparison of Costellos Argument to the Contradictory Perspectives of Nagel, Locke, and Wallace

This essay "Animals and Humans" considers Costello's argument that humans must rely on powers of sympathy and empathy, and compares it to the contradictory perspectives of thomas Nagel, John Locke and David Foster Wallace.... This essay considers Costello's argument and compares it to the contradictory perspectives of thomas Nagel, John Locke, and David Foster Wallace.... n considering the nature of the mind-body question, thomas Nagel reflects on the nature of consciousness....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Understanding the Motives and the Causes of Impulses Into International Relationships

The paper describes the objective of political authority to protect the rights of its subjects and ensuring a stable society.... A stable society is that which is free from civil strife because the members of the state share common good and resources in a way that does not infringe into the rights of others....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Summary of the Articles by Albert Camus, Thomas Nagel and Prichard

This article "Summary of the Articles by Albert Camus, Thomas Nagel and Prichard" focuses on Camus who reveals the limitations of Absurd, Nagel who discusses the issue of moral assessment and Prichard who tries to dissect the subject of moral philosophy.... nbsp;… Just as a common man is afraid of the moral philosophers, moral philosophers are afraid of violation of morality by the mass of people, as such they seek theoretical validation of morality....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us