StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Human Function Argument - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Human Function Argument" focuses on Aristotle who had tried to prove the human function relating it with the goodness of human beings, but failed to establish his arguments owing to a lack of pieces of evidence on the premises he discussed, against questions and criticisms. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Human Function Argument
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Human Function Argument"

Aristotle’s Human Function Argument: Based on the human function argument, Aristotle had argued that a clear concept of happiness can be realized if the human function could be studied and understood. It reflects that every function or activity of human beings contains the goodness or happiness in it based on the rationality of the function. Thus with the rational part of the human soul performing an activity or a particular function, goodness or happiness takes place. Aristotle had considered happiness to be the best good that could have happened to a human being.

Thus in order to determine the goodness in man, Aristotle’s function argument states that the function of the human needs to be ascertained. Also, according to him, human life has been stated to be common to plants, as well as to animals thereby having an active life element with rationality (Korsgaard 129-132). The arguments presented by Aristotle as part of the function argument includes: “(1) Humans must have a function, or else they would be idle, which is absurd; (2) Each human body part has a function, so the whole human must likewise have a function; (3) The human function is unique to only humans themselves; (4)Human function is not growth and nutrition because these aspects of life are shared with plant; (5)Human function is not sense perception because this aspect of life is shared with an animal; (6)The part of the human soul with reason is unique to human; (7) The bare capacity of the reason is insufficient to constitute a life function; and (8) Therefore, the human function is the activity of the part of the soul that expresses or requires reason” (Pritchett).

Failure of the Function Argument: Although Aristotle tried his best to determine the human function reflecting the happiness and goodness factors in humans, his beliefs could not stand alone against the questions and criticisms that were raised. Aristotle could not place his arguments successfully as he lacked supportive arguments over the premises he focused on. He could not explain the reason for the human function to be considered unique. When he said that human function is common to plants, it raised questions on the fact as to how two things can be similar only because they share some activities in common.

Also, when he stated about animals, it is not clear whether he meant to say that humans only have functions and animals do not have any function. Different functions can be associated with different features or the same function can be presented in different ways by different individuals or animals. Hence Aristotle’s arguments could not present clearly the meanings of the premises (Pritchett). Critics also could not realize how the goodness of a human being can be associated with the good performance or activity of the individual even if there is a function present in human beings.

Questions could be raised on several thoughts. For example, even if it is believed to be true that the goodness of a human is based on the good activity of the human, the question arises whether it is good to be a good human or whether the goodness of every single human can be determined the same, and so on (Korsgaard 131). Thus the uniqueness of human function could not be proved by Aristotle through his arguments. Evidence was also lacking that could prove two different life forms to be similar. Assumption of things could not be considered as correct that could lead to wrong premises as had been presented by Aristotle (Pritchett).

Conclusion:

From the above study, it could be obtained that Aristotle had tried to prove the human function relating it with the goodness of human beings, but failed to establish his arguments owing to lack of shreds of evidence on the premises he discussed, against questions and criticisms. It can be said that in order to prove his points, further research and analysis would be necessary such that the premises could be modified and actually connected with each other successfully establishing the argument of human function.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 10”, n.d.)
Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 10. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1487130-ethics
(Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 10)
Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 10. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1487130-ethics.
“Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 10”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1487130-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Human Function Argument

Moral Significance of Personhood

According to the text, Christian creationist theology - with its scheme that places the human being above all of God's creations - is the foundation of the moral argument in the discourse of personhood.... The teleological argument has been largely done away with as advances in reproductive technology, medical genetics, and treatments continually assail the rationality of God and his hand in the affairs of the humans.... The author of the essay highlights the fact, the idea is that a person owes its identity and personhood to the soul, reinforcing the principle that human life is sacred, requiring respect and recognition of its dignity....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Case Against Physicalism By Jacky Chang

Alter(2005) uses Descartes' argument, that phenomenal consciousness is not physical due to the fact that one can conceive of the body as well as the mind independently of each other, therefore, phenomenal consciousness is neither functional nor physical, to prove that we have a fully conscious mind and a fully present body.... Melynk (2007) uses the argument that choice cannot be free as it refers to a causal agent or, in the case of theism, a supposed intentional agent that predesigned or had prior knowledge of that choice....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Is the Creation of Artificial Humans with Human Ability Real

The essay will evaluate the two arguments and give a personal supported opinion that is against computationalism, the reason being the impossibility of scientists to create systems similar to humans', thus the weakness of Dennett's argument.... The main point of his argument is based on his perspective that a consciousness machine is in no way different from a perpetual one in that both can be programmed to execute specific functions by use of physical processes....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Line Managers in HR Function

In the paper 'Line Managers in HR function,' the author analyzes the management of human resources, which is considered an activity that is carried out by all managers.... Sako and Tierney (2005) state that Business Transformation Outsourcing (BTO) is an emerging segment, which focuses on improving the effectiveness of an entire corporate function like the HR.... The rationale is to outsource administrative tasks leaving the personnel to focus on strategy formulation using their competencies (Sako & Tierney) and to experience greater flexibility in allocating resources, and greater cost efficiencies (Jones & Finlayson, 1999) but Khatri and Budhwar (2002) cite many scholars who argue that human resource can be a source of sustainable competitive advantage for an organization....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Teleological Arguments for the Existence of God

"Teleological Arguments for the Existence of God" paper seeks to contend through the teleological philosophical argument that God does actually exists and to this end, it examines some of the major arguments that have been posited in support of his presence.... To some, the existence of God is axiomatic; they base their argument of faith and claim that those who oppose them do so from spiritual ignorance and naivety.... Conversely, others are just as sure about his nonexistence basing their argument mostly on the fact that there is insufficient proof of his existence....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Relationship between Form and Function in Architecture

To bring out the argument of his perception of skyscraper design and for the rising structure character, he claimed that his design represented a natural outcome of all-pervading laws.... This paper is therefore towards looking into the function and form in the prehistoric times and the argument behind the maxim 'Form follows Function'.... This work called "Relationship between Form and function in Architecture" describes the function as the major consideration of architecture and the importance of form in architecture....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Approaches to the Study of Cross Linguistic Concepts

Considerably, the subject notion is principally imperative as the argument remains that, for certain languages, the subject is a compulsory component of every sentence.... Arguments similar to the ones used in favor of the PRO subject analysis in infinitive clauses of English can be employed to identify that there is also a null pronoun in such clauses, under which supposition might an individual argue that the sentences above also entail an unsound pronoun subject, even if of course there can merely be argument utilizing the existence of meaning to maintain the supposition of the pronoun existence....
17 Pages (4250 words) Research Paper

The Concept of Aristotle's Function Argument

This is "The Concept of Aristotle's function argument" essay.... he concept of Aristotle's function argument, it is Aristotle's perception that it will be essential to comprehend the function theory as employed to human beings.... According to Aristotle, it is perceived that the human function is the conscious venture that is everyone's good and should be carried out properly.... In the novel by Aristotle, book 1 of Nicomachean Ethics, there is an argument that there exist two things, the good and well....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us