StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Hosmers Ethical Theory Issues - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Hosmer's Ethical Theory Issues" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in Hosmer's Ethical Theory. One needs to propound an accurate answer to this question by analysing the three most important and most relevant theories on ethics…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Hosmers Ethical Theory Issues
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Hosmers Ethical Theory Issues"

Based on the various answers to the 9 vital questions in Hosmer's Ethical theory, I will propound an accurate answer to this question by analysing the three most important and most relevant theories on ethics. I will select the most appropriate answer based on the theories themselves and not my personal opinion.

Hosmer's theory, in a nutshell, states that managers must be morally responsible in other for the following to happen:
- Moral behaviour generates trust among stakeholders.
- Trust leads to stakeholders' commitment.
- Commitments increase stakeholders' efforts and
- Increased stakeholder effort increases corporate success.

In other words, Hosmer's theory bases its arguments on the fact that moral behaviours make a business sound. Hosmer's text, in comparison to Kant, appears to be a managerial text that uses ethics in support of management, thus constituting 'knowledge in the service of power', i.e. ideology. But ethics is not ideology. Ethical philosophy was developed in Greek antiquity by great and renowned philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle. They maintain that ethics would; for example, demand that managers, IR experts, and trade unionists be honest, helpful, cooperative, sincere, open, benevolent, and modest. But, Hosmer avoids such a relevant list in his theory (185).

Another challenge for management and its ideological outgrowth of managerialism--comes from utilitarianism theory as discussed by (Johnson, Hosmer, Pogge and Horton). Utilitarian ethics is directed towards creating the greatest good for the greatest number of people. Trade unions (Johnson) and many international organisations (Pogge/Horton) work towards this goal. Management according to (Hosmer, 2008), however, has other goals and agendas which are primarily to make a profit. This sole purpose as an end in itself, rules out this theory as being ethically justifiable (p14), (P4), and (p1-14).

Kant's ethics creates substantial problems for management, but not for trade unions (Johnson) and the international level (Pogge/Horton). Kant's first and foremost categorical imperative is to act universally. This means that whenever someone acts morally, this person should also act as if humanity as a whole was concerned. This is one key area that management writers such as Hosmer, tend to avoid. They either completely avoid these ethical imperatives, or downplay them. Hosmer also diminishes Kant's second imperative, the ‘means-ends dictum’. It is also downplayed by Johnson who sees the Kantian means-ends problem simply to mean, 'managers shouldn't coerce or threaten employees' In reality, Kant's means-ends imperative demands that workers are never treated as a 'means', or as a tool or instrument. According to Kant, a worker represents an 'end in itself' which is the most truth and reality so far as ethics and morals are concerned. Kant's categorical imperatives are 'musts', which have to be strictly adhered to. In essence, either one treats workers as an 'end in themselves' and thereby behaves ethically, or one uses them as a 'means' and behaves unethically, there are no in-betweens. Kant's categorical imperative does not leave room for 'ifs', 'buts', and 'maybes'. Also, one finds that Hegel's ethical concept of Sittlichkeit which is a globally recognized socially constructed ethics; is only discussed by Pogge/Horton. By avoiding Kant's means-ends dictum and Hegel's concept of Sittlichkeit, Hosmer and Johnson have failed to see that the treatment of workers as means renders management and capitalism as a whole, very unethical.

Based on this account, the most appropriate ethical theory is the theory of the German philosopher; Immanuel Kant. His theory on ethics represents the most influential writings on ethics. And so back to our case study on Chevron, the Kants theory should be applied in resolving the ethical issues. The health and safety of the employees should first be respected and taken into consideration before any other profit and environmental factor is concerned. Secondly, the Environment should be considered and pollution and contamination tackled due to the universal human rights consideration as propounded by Kant. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“On chevron article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1408463-on-chevron-article
(On Chevron Article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/other/1408463-on-chevron-article.
“On Chevron Article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1408463-on-chevron-article.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Hosmers Ethical Theory Issues

Should Hooters Ban Children's Attendance after 9 PM

There is also a wide array of ethical theories and explanations that are present, each one holding a particular merit, but the lack of uniformity and coherence makes it hard to standardize or decide on a single formula or framework to deal with such issues.... We will now analyze this case in light of three schools of ethical reasoning: Ethical Egoism: This is a Teleological or consequentiality based theory which assesses morality based on the consequences on an individual, which in this case would be the moral agent....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Ethical Integrity in a Business

Larue (1987) perceived that ethical issues relating to business management are most discussed as a relevant matter in human resource management.... Hosmer (1987) posited that ethical issues are foremost considered when workers experienced being harmed or at a loss especially when the company undertakes restructuring or closure.... Organizational justice: A behavioral science concept with critical implications for business ethics and stakeholder theory....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

History of Business Ethics and Ethical Theory

This essay "History of Business Ethics and ethical theory" is focused on the theory of business ethics.... These are some of the unethical issues common to businesses in the contemporary world.... As the author puts it, business ethics emerged in the mid-1970s owing to the failure of ethical practices in the business.... Corporate social responsibility is a major ethical consideration in a company since it shows that the entity is mindful of the peoples' welfare....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ethical Issues in Multinational Organizations

The paper will view the different ethical issues as indicated by the Abraham's Stakeholder model and try to figure out the strength of these ethical issues as would determine the success of human resource management and progressive development in a company operating multi-nationally.... Multinational organizations face a collection of problems and issues in their operations.... This literature is based on ethical issues in organizations and will broadly look at ethical issues and the different stakeholders associated with these issues in different capacities....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Business Ethics: Managing Corporate Citizenship and Sustainability in the Age of Globalization

Examples of ethical issues concerning three different issues have been explained along with their alleged lawsuits that have flagged these issues in the United States.... usiness ethics are the moral eternal, abstract, and the unchangeable principles and values that determine decision making and right or wrong of contextual issues related to business or profession in accordance with ethical problems such as issues relating to human rights, privacy, discrimination, sexual and other types of harassment, performance evaluation, hiring, firing, safety, security, etc....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Current Issues in Business Ethics

The essay "Current issues in Business Ethics" focuses on the critical analysis of the major current issues in business ethics.... Business Ethics are considered a form of applied ethics that attempts to understand and explore the issues related to businesses and ethics.... Introduction Business Ethics are considered as form of applied ethics which attempt to understand and explore the issues related with the businessesand ethics....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Nike Ethical Audit Issue

It is quite evidence that Nike need to overcome its ethical issues through the use of ethical theory.... Hill (2009) maintains that, the best ethical theory that can be used to solve Nikes ethical issues is utilitarianism.... Nike's ethical dilemma issues have dominated the media in the recent years which has adversely affected the image of the company.... These issues range from corporate issues, child labor, employee's exploitation and legal matters....
11 Pages (2750 words) Report

Analyzing Business Ethics in Two Movies - Wall Street and Election

These movies involve issues to do with business ethics and theories.... These movies involve issues to do with business ethics and theories.... These movies involve issues to do with business ethics and theories.... There are numerous ethical issues that face both Fox and Gekko.... Nonetheless, the main difference is that Wall Street portrays ethical issues in the business context, while Election portrays ethics in the political and school context....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us