StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The chemical was sprinkled over a field of cabbages owned by Arthur, who underwent more than £100,000 damaged to the crop. Brownings Ltd. deny negligence, and it is very unlikely that Arthur will not be…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law)"

EU Law In the provided case study a hazardous chemical escaped from Brownings Ltd. The chemical was sprinkled over a field of cabbages owned by Arthur, who underwent more than £100,000 damaged to the crop. Brownings Ltd. deny negligence, and it is very unlikely that Arthur will not be able to recover damages under English Law. One has to study this case in two dimensions. First dimension is that if 00/1271/EC Directive would have been implemented in the UK by 1 January 2002. Under this Directive anyone storing or manufacturing hazardous material is strictly liable to compensate those affected by their escape, irrespective of fault.

Arthur would have been compensated for the damage of £100,000 of the cabbages field. Other dimension is the present situation that 00/1271/EC Directive has not been implemented yet. Brownings Ltd. should put up this situation as an accident that results in damage to Arthur’s fields as well as the premises of Brownings Ltd. By putting the case in such manner will prevent Brownings Ltd. to pay compensation to Arthur. Under this situation both parties has to move towards the insurance organizations for the damages incurred to them.

By means of regard to the straight effect of directives, the European court of justice has detained in Marshall v. Southampton AHA that orders can only be imposed against the State since art 249 EC Treaty conveys that a instruction is obligatory upon each Member State to whom it is dealt; it does not present that it trusses persons.  Consequently until United Kingdom actually applies the directive it would be iniquitous to permit it to be imposed against non-governmental bodies. Arthur is looking for implementing the Directive in opposition to Brownings.

As it is provided in the case study that Brownings is a limited organization that have possession of a large chemical works.  If one applies the three Foster criteria that are provision of a government service; under the control of the State; and having exceptional powers; to it, as Brownings obviously is not providing a state service, so due to this reason it would not be an emanation of the State.  Though the European court of justice in Kampelmann has recommended that the Foster criteria may not be cumulative, and therefore offered one of the three criteria is fulfilled, the body will be an emanation of the State.

  Conversely, this fraction of the judgment may well be wrong, and it is completely practicable that the three criteria are cumulative.  Yet if they are not cumulative, it is doubtful that Brownings would gratify any of the three criteria and consequently the Directive could not be imposed directly against them.  

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law) Essay”, n.d.)
My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law) Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535774-my-second-problem-base-question-eu-law
(My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law) Essay)
My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law) Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535774-my-second-problem-base-question-eu-law.
“My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535774-my-second-problem-base-question-eu-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF My Second - Problem Base Question (EU Law)

Business Enivronemnts

This research project is being carried out to evaluate and present Network Diagram - Activity on node.... The researcher of this essay aims to note the introduction of a dummy activity R with duration of zero to represent the end of the project.... hellip; The current paper presents the details of the study, Determination of Timing of Activities and Total Float, Critical Path and Project Duration, Limitations of Network Diagram....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

European Union problem question

ccording to the Article 15 of eu law, every person has the right to work and seek job in any member state.... However, the description of “family member” must comprise the registered companion, if the law of host country treats registered companion as comparable to marriage.... The legal structure practiced in foreign states can act together with the law of UK in a complicated manner, and therefore the direction of ‘surrogate or registrar' is essential in order to avoid complications in marriage and immigration problem in the UK or Netherlands....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Law Problem Questions

This paper ''law Problem Questions'' tells that According to the Criminal Justice Act of 2003, it is common knowledge that it is possible to charge someone with a crime for which there is insufficient hard evidence, but ample circumstantial evidence.... hellip; Based upon the reputation that daily builds one's character, law enforcement officials can piece together a story for the judge that details what this person's life is like, what his usual routines are, and other details that might be substantially important in deciding one's guilt or innocence....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Acquis Communautaire or Body of EU Law

The paper "European Union law" tells us about the body of common rights and obligations which bind all the Member States within the European Union.... hellip; This means that while EC law creates many substantive rules of law, the means by which these are enforced is the responsibility of national law.... In other words, EC rules of law must take their place just like ordinary rules of national law, depending on their availability and enforcement according to national procedural rules....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Substantive Law of the EU

Therefore subject to the application of the doctrine of direct effect in this regard S and A might have a possible remedy under eu law.... The directive was to be transposed into UK law on the 1st of January and the time has expired as at now .... It seems here that the UK does not have a defence that could be raised for non compliance because under Art 10EC the member states are required to fulfill all their community law obligations and Art 292 obliges Member States not to seek other solutions to disputes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Supremacy of EU Law

Researchers have revealed how the ECJ extended the span of European law with the intention that litigants possibly will use the European legal system to support trade in Europe, and to encourage essential substantive and political goals linked with European assimilation.... hellip; The reliability of EC law is made certain by its supremacy over national law and this is the fundamental value of EC law when developed by means of the European Court of Justice....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

E-commerce law in European Union

“EU E-Commerce law May Undermine Human Rights, Group Says”.... Between 2006 and 2008, the eu shoppers buying at the minimum one product from the virtual arena increased from 27% to 33% (up to 91% in the Nordic countries).... Hardly 7%… There are a number of reasons assigned for this comparatively low figure, which include language barriers besides some practical, governance or goodwill-related problems....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Competition Law: EU Law on SGEIs

This essay looks at the eu law on SGEIs and analyzes whether the law strikes a balance between the provision of public services and the law on competition in the internal market.... SGEI is a constitutional concept in eu law where it is subject to articles of Article 14 of TFEU, and it is subject to the Protocol of SGEIs.... hellip; This essay looked at what laws apply to SGEI and completion law in the internal market in relation to SGEI.... It shows necessity especially by case law used....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us