StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Assignment 3 for CLS325 - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
Strengths and Weaknesses of the Methods in Analyzing Cultural Texts and Practices Even as cultural studies continue to evolve, a debate among scholars on the most scientific and accurate methods in analyzing cultural texts and practices remains very much alive…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Assignment 3 for CLS325
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Assignment 3 for CLS325"

Download file to see previous pages

This paper attempts to present the strengths and weaknesses of the two methods. The text-centered method of analyzing culture is considered as imperative in studying social context. Norman Fairclough explains that the theoretical basis for this concept is based on the fact that text itself is the product of people’s perspectives on the society in which they belong. He also points out that “texts constitute a major source of evidence for grounding claims about social, structures, relations and processes.” (209) In relation to the aforementioned points, it is, therefore, clear that texts serve as effective means of achieving a profound understanding of culture and society.

On the other hand, these also serve as powerful instruments of shaping or influencing culture and society, in general, as well. However, there is an apparent weakness in just limiting the analysis of culture and society according to what the text provides. The text itself may not be able to provide an accurate impression unless this is related to the actual conditions that surround it. According to Urpo Kovala, “the first characteristic of cultural analysis of texts… is that textual analysis be contextual.

” (Cultural Studies and Cultural Text Analysis) It is by getting a more comprehensive picture, which may include knowing the author of the text and the personal and social conditions which he or she is in, that a better appreciation of the textual work produced is achieved. The text should, therefore, not be taken as it is but should be related to the context in which it was made. In this regard, its relevance or irrelevance should be understood through the reception of the readers or the receivers.

Otherwise, textualism or the text-centered method could be outright weak. The weakness of the text-centered method of analyzing culture is that it tends to be detached from other conditions that may actually be related to the text itself. By merely relying on the text and disregarding the other aspects that may have influenced its deliverer or creator, analysis becomes vulnerable to one-sidedness and, ultimately, inaccuracy. The reaction of the audience, which is important in determining the practical relevance of the text, also tends to be disregarded when making a text-centered analysis.

This inherent weakness of textualism is the reason why Douglas Kellner suggests three aspects to consider in employing a text-centered method in analyzing culture. These are the “production and political economy of culture; textual analysis and critique of its artifacts; and a study of audience reception and the uses of media/cultural products.” (Kellner 8) All three must be taken into consideration when analyzing culture using the text-centered method. It must be noted that Kellner already mentions the significance of audience impression.

Therefore, in an attempt to overcome the weakness of the text-centered method, some concerns that centers on the audience has to be applied. Hence, the method actually loses its being absolutely text-centered. In New Keywords: The Revised Vocabulary of Culture and Society, Terry Threadgold correctly sumps up the point that “the text is engage in a continuous play of meaning across the field on intertextuality… at the very least, the meaning is mobile, dispersed, and plural, since any text is always subject to the incessant movement of recontextualization.”

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Assignment 3 for CLS325 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1406223-assignment
(Assignment 3 for CLS325 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1406223-assignment.
“Assignment 3 for CLS325 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1406223-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Assignment 3 for CLS325

Active Continental Margin and Passive Continental Margin

While an active continental margin exists on the edge of the continent, where it comes into contact with the oceanic plate, passive continental margins exist on the rest of the… Because of the crashing effect between continental and oceanic plates, active continental margins experience a lot of tectonic activities, resulting into earthquakes, creation of igneous rock, The landscape is, therefore, irregular, comprising both hills and valleys; hence, resulting in short rivers....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Written Assignments: Field Trip Viewing Assignment

TITLE: LEDA AND THE SWAN ARTIST NAME: JOHN COVERT… MEDIUM: OIL ON CANVAS ESTIMATED SIZE: 24 INCHES × 18 INCHES DATE WORK WAS MADE: 1915-1923 GALLERY WHERE VIEWED: HENRY ART GALLERY WORK MADE IN THE USA The entire portrait plus its background is brown in color, with slight variation in the color's intensity....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

What Are the Goals and Objectives of Robin Hood and His Band

The actual objectives of Robin Hood and his band are to establish an organizing group, which will help the cluster to perform their task as a single troop of army with a common goal and desire.... Thus, the objective of Rabin Hood and his band can be compared with large… Moreover, Robin Hood and his band are trying to live outside the law of the Sheriff and his administration....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Performance Appraisal Scale

Outstanding – Demonstrates outstanding performance and competency in the use of skills and in the application of knowledge in fulfilling assignments and/or delivering patient care with results significantly exceeding the requirements for the position. Satisfactory Plus (Above… Standard) – Demonstrates proficiency in the use of skills and in the application of knowledge in fulfilling assignments and/or delivering patient care with results often exceeding requirements of the position Satisfactory (Average) – Demonstrates capable performance in the Performance appraisal scale Outstanding – Demonstrates outstanding performance and competency in the use of skills and in the application of knowledge in fulfilling assignments and/or delivering patient care with results significantly exceeding the requirements for the position....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Femtosecond Probing of Reaction

Light intensity provides sufficient energy for the process of photosynthesis, increase in light intensity results to proportionate increase in the rate of photosynthesis up to the optimum level.... The proposed process as per the paper is energy-dependent quenching. Through… Molecules at S0, S1, and S2 have distinguishing characteristics....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The Creation Teachings in Christianity

Several religions acknowledge the importance of the environment and appreciate human efforts in conserving it.... Environmental mismanagement, however, has been attributed to the wrong religious interpretations… Islam as well as Christianity teaches about the responsibility that everyone has on the environment....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Logics of Database Analysis

… )c) specifying that the subject of a message must not be longer than 120 characters, in SQL is by using the term text(120) as shown in the diagram below CREATE TABLE Colors ( MessageID LONG, PRIMARY KEY, MessageSubject TEXT(120) Message Body )c) specifying that the subject of a message must not be longer than 120 characters, in SQL is by using the term text(120) as shown in the diagram below CREATE TABLE Colors ( MessageID LONG, PRIMARY KEY, MessageSubject TEXT(120) Message Body TEXT(100) SendDate LONG )d) Enforcing the restriction that the only valid values of sex are male or female, in SQL is as shownCREATE TABLE Client ( EmailAdress LONG, ClientName TEXT(40), Gender TEXT (10), CONSTRAINT PK_Male and female PRIMARY KEY ClienthouseholdSize LONG, clientaddress )Question 3Entity – Relationship Diagram (E R Diagram) The database to create will contain various entities which include member details, client details contacts and contracts....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us