StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Segregated Provision - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the "Segregated Provision" paper answers whether he/she agrees or disagrees with the statement that the existence of segregated provision represents a serious violation of students' human rights, including but not only - the right to properly supported inclusive education…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
The Segregated Provision
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Segregated Provision"

INTRODUCTION The primary goal of education is to train and equip or learners with knowledge and information that is necessary for their survival and general development of the society. In the pursuit of this goal, governments through their education systems have to come up with standard curricular which clearly outlines methods to be used for standard teaching without the need for additional support to students. In the establishment of a good and practical education system, students’ human rights must be protected (Libby, 1990). Such rights include but are not limited to the right to properly supported and inclusive education. On the other hand, educators, and governments by extension, face a great challenge in dealing with students with special needs whose rights must also not be infringed. According to Kavale (2002), special needs for learners commonly include communication challenges, physical disabilities, behavioural and emotional disorders, developmental disabilities and learning disabilities. SEGREGATED PROVISION In light of the facts stated above, it has often become necessary for education systems to establish ways and means of providing special services to students with unique needs in order to meet their special learning needs separate from their “normal” peers. One common measure of intervention taken to address this often unavoidable situation is through the application of segregated provision (Libby, 1990). Indeed, common knowledge has it that children who are mentally retarded, hearing and visually impaired and sometimes physically disabled cannot learn maximally under conditions provided in the common classroom and as such need special facilities to facilitate and aid their learning and development. In other words, students with specific disabilities will most likely benefit more from different teaching approaches, additional education services and different use of technology that aid their learning. Segregated provision may generally imply separating learners with certain disabilities, limitations or exceptional qualities from their peers (or mainstream life) and providing them with more or less similar educational services in special units, schools, classes or sanctuaries – a measure that, according to certain quarters, goes against the inclusive aspect of students’ human rights (Kavale, 2002). Segregation in this sense implies separation from the normal whether fulltime/permanently or part time/temporarily. The main goal of special education is to address the particular combination of special needs and differences of an individual student. In order for this to be successfully accomplished, many times, students with special needs are separated or segregated from their peers and taught in a setting different from that which is generally established. Special education which in many cases involves segregated provision has a lot to do with individually planned and well monitored means of teaching, accessible settings, adapted materials and equipment, and certain other interventions that are put in place to help learners with unique needs realize a higher level of success and self-sufficiency than would be attained if he/she were to have access to the typical classroom training (Libby, 1990). INTEGRATED AND INCLUSIVE EDUCATION Integration generally implies meeting educational needs of students in ordinary schools as opposed to those that have a policy of segregation (Kavale, 2002). This kind of approach emphasizes the need to meet particular needs of learners and managing special needs within a mainstream school rather than categorising these cases in the assumption that specialist schools are the better option. In this regard, certain measures are taken to accommodate learners with special needs. The concept of inclusion on the other hand considers a school as a place where needs of all children should be met without having special cases identified and separated into categories (Kavale, 2002). Learners with special needs are thus included the school’s normal system of operation without offering specialist support. This approach to education involves incorporating different curriculum and organisational structures which cater for the varied needs of all learners – including those with special needs. Some experts argue that this approach is both relevant and beneficial to the entire school community and is in harmony with statutory law. Although having good intentions, there are quite a number of dilemmas hat this approach faces in its application. One main aspect is the contradiction that exists between meeting individual’s needs (which basically involves differentiation) and attempting to treat all learners equally (Kavale, 2002). These dilemmas, which remain impossible to resolve, can however be managed by for instance by grouping by ability and encouraging within-class support. Inclusion and integration, as opposed to segregation, are widely believed to improve academic achievement for many students and also helps in reducing social stigmas. STUDENTS’ RIGHTS The inherent right to education is a universally accepted recognition. This basically means that each and every person has the right to gain knowledge and acquire information. Education must also be accessible under such frameworks as are totally general and absolutely non-discriminatory (Libby, 1990). Furthermore, all standards, contents and dynamics of education must be fundamentally acceptable and basically adaptable to new and current concepts in view of its evolutionary character1. The right to education is specifically provided for in Article 26 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. With these universal policies and strong statements, every person is considered to have that inherent and inborn right to gain knowledge and information through a well established system of education. A necessary complement to the right to education is the right not to be discriminated against in the exercise thereof. It is thus outlined and stressed by UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) in a 1960 convention that discrimination on matters of the right to education is totally and absolutely prohibited. Under the afore-mentioned UNESCO convention, the policy against discrimination covers that which distinguishes, excludes, limits or gives preference in making available educational privileges on the basis of race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, economic condition or birth. Discriminating a person on any of these grounds may be comparable or likened to unequal treatment. As specifically described by UNESCO in Article 26 of 1960, discrimination is not allowed in every type and level of education and is meant to include any act that seeks to deny accessibility to education and its rightful standard and quality, and also the conditions which make it available. Generally speaking, the existence of any act of segregation that is harmful to learners’ development represents a violation of the students’ human rights and should not be allowed at all costs. Segregated provision that is directed towards benefiting learners with special needs however does not fall under the adverse meaning of discrimination that is meant to be prohibited by every possible means. Under the 1981 Education Act, Local Education Authorities (LEAs) have the duty of educating students with special learning needs in ordinary schools (Long, 2001) under an inclusive educational system. Exceptions to this act however exist in the following paragraph of the statutes. SEGREGATED PROVISION AND STUDENTS’ RIGHTS The practice of segregated provision has been a subject of great debate and concern. Some people argue that learners with abnormally low abilities need protection and support from their normal peers - something they cannot receive under a segregated learning setup. Others also hold the belief that segregation can be limiting and divisive against the goal of education. Furthermore, it has been argued by some that segregated provision does not necessarily lead to better learning outcomes and is thus of no positive consequence (Long, 2001). This may be seen for example in the consideration of students with disruptive behaviour; further separation would ultimately aggravate the negative condition (Oakford & Hastings, 2003). This view is particularly supported by results of a number of studies including one research that was conducted on the effectiveness of education that showed significant differences in learning progress among students with special needs (Oakford & Hastings, 2003). The results established that such students showing better progress under an integrated or ordinary school setting compared to those who were under segregated conditions. Further, an evaluation by HMI, as recorded in a 1992 Audit Commission report, found no significant differences in results between the two settings. Under these circumstances, it could well be considered that students put under segregated conditions had their rights violated. Under the most stringent interpretation of statutes, the existence of a segregated provision is the same as discriminating or classifying or dictating preferences on matters involving the right to education and is therefore a violation of the human rights of a discriminated student. Since the right to education is a fundamental and basic right, the violation even through the existence of a segregated provision is an offense committed to the concerned student. It is equivalent to a deprivation of access to education or putting a limit to such rights, or of encouraging the development of separate systems of education. CONCLUSION In view of the above arguments, it is noted that there are acceptable acts of segregation. These however are founded on the basis of aiding the process of learning for students with special needs and sound public policies. As such, these acts are not considered to go against students’ rights and are therefore considered acceptable by the implementing state or government. This in essence implies that whatever is done in the best interest of a student with a learning (mental, visual, hearing and other physical) disability, although seemingly discriminatory, may not in effect amount to infringing his/her right as a student. This said, learning institutions must endeavour to establish a system that is inclusive and supportive in line with the provisions of the established laws. What should also be done to avoid violating students’ rights is the creation of a system or institution that will offer equivalent access to education and will provide a teaching staff with qualifications of the appropriate standards to segregated learners. It must also provide school premises and equipment of good quality and must make available the opportunity to learn same or equivalent courses of study. REFERENCES Kavale, K. A. (2002), Mainstreaming to full inclusion-from orthogenesis to pathogenesis of an ide, International Journal of Disability, Development, and Education, page 48, 200-207. Libby, G. (1990), Time and learning in the special education classroom, Albany, University of New York Press, NewYork State. Long, M. (2001), Psychology of education, RoutledgeFalmer, (1st ed), London, UK. Nesara International, The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: A Magna Carta for all Humanity, Article 26, Retrieved on July 25, 2009 from http://nesara.insights2.org/UNHumanRights.html Oakford, S. & Hastings, R.P., (2003) Student teachers attitudes toward the inclusion of children with special needs, Educational Psychology, page 22, 86-87. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Segregated Provision Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
The Segregated Provision Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/education/1725711-the-existence-of-segregated-provision-represents-a-serious-violation-of-students-human-rightsincluding-but-not-only-the-right-to-properly-supportedinclusive-education-2007to-what-extent-do-you-agree-or-disagree-with-this-statment
(The Segregated Provision Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
The Segregated Provision Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/education/1725711-the-existence-of-segregated-provision-represents-a-serious-violation-of-students-human-rightsincluding-but-not-only-the-right-to-properly-supportedinclusive-education-2007to-what-extent-do-you-agree-or-disagree-with-this-statment.
“The Segregated Provision Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/education/1725711-the-existence-of-segregated-provision-represents-a-serious-violation-of-students-human-rightsincluding-but-not-only-the-right-to-properly-supportedinclusive-education-2007to-what-extent-do-you-agree-or-disagree-with-this-statment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Segregated Provision

Dawm valley hospital : selecting quality measures for the hospital board

For instance, where the process scores are high, leading to high avoidance rates could mean that the quality of health care provision is high while low process scores, leading to low avoidance rates could mean low quality in health care provision.... The Board requested for an aggregated quality score monthly because the monthly aggregated quality score was to include a representation of quality and safety at each of the facilities of Dawn Valley Hospital, as a whole....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

FREE MOVEMENT OF PERSONS IN EU LOW

The fundamental problem at hand was whether the provision could be enforced horizontally- against a private party by such a party- as Sabena Airline was classified as a private party, albeit with the state as a majority shareholder, on the basis that it was constituted under private law, and with staff under private contracts of employment.... However, the case retains its credibility as the court segregated the principle of equal work, within the article, with the factual uncertainties regarding the terms stipulated....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Segregation Should Be a Phenomenon of the Past

The writer suggests an action-driven solution in the sense that the writer wants to see the transportation of segregated students to White schools, where they can learn about the culture of other people and how to socialize easily with these people.... The reason for this argument was fused in the believe that when people are segregated one from another, they do not come to accept the personality of other people and as such have no inner regrets when they are offending them....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

African Americans as the Vulnerable Population

Within the United States, racial segregation often implied the physical separation together with provision of separate services or facilities (mostly during the era of Jim Crow), although it could also refer to other distinct racial discrimination manifestations.... The former confederates, southern legislatures opted to pass laws popularly regarded as black codes, which immensely limited the blacks' rights and subsequently segregated them from the white community....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Right to Workin in the Development of Businesses and the Economy

hellip; It sought to include a provision that was later called the 'right to work' laws.... This legal provision was timely in order to offer freedom and equality for all citizens to pursue and acquire employment opportunities equally, at a time when the existing professionals were placing constraints on aspiring candidates.... hose who advocate for the for the right-to-work mainly point of its provision that seeks to elaborate that the ban on union shops reduces the ability of the labor unions to control their workers and maintain their allegiance to the union....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Liberty, Equality, Power - a History of the American People

Furthermore, mobilization brought about civil rights; Africa Americans serving in were less likely to be segregated.... It was used to describe the preparation of the army of Prussia for deployment.... The era of mobilization involved the allocation of nation's resources for the preparation, assembly and equipping of… This process of preparing armies for war started in the middle of the nineteenth century....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Shame of a nation

In a poor child's school career, the provision of amenities is limited.... The rich should be able to provide financially and help build better schools as well as provide the equipment that should help contribute to the provision of better education to these children.... The most segregated state of the state is New York and the school by the name Martin Luther king is the most segregated and he wonders why give such a big name to the poor schools....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Court Cases That Impacts the Opportunity in Education

The case was elevated to the Supreme Court wherein through a unanimous decision, the ruling was reversed in favour of Brown stating “that enforced segregations is a basis of inequality and is a violation of the fourteenth amendments equality provision.... Board of Education in 1954 wherein parents protested against segregated facilities in public schools for black and white children.... Board of Education in 1954 wherein parents protested against segregated facilities in public schools for black and white children....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us