StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Pure Observational Approach - Essay Example

Summary
The researcher of this essay examines two articles: “Reflections on Participant Observation in Drugs Research” by Robert Power and “The Girls in the Gang: A Report from New York City” by Annie Campbell. Robert Power (2001) argues the importance and impact of a time consuming observational approach…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
The Pure Observational Approach
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Pure Observational Approach"

The Pure Observational Approach Introduction There are many ways in which drug research are being conducted. Over the years, some drug research focuses on pure qualitative research method including personal interviews (Griffiths et al., 1993) and self-reports while others are being conducted based on observational approach mixed with qualitative research method or simply by pure observational approach (Feldman, 1968). In the past, researchers have tried combining different strategies related to anthropology, journalism, as well as sociology in terms of uncovering the truth behind the use of illegal drugs. (Faris, 1967) With regards to different approaches in conducting research study on illegal drugs, the researcher will compare and contrast a couple of authors’ personal opinion with regards to this matter. In the process, the researcher will examine two articles: “Reflections on Participant Observation in Drugs Research” by Robert Power and “The Girls in the Gang: A Report from New York City” by Annie Campbell. The Main Arguments and Contradictions between the Point-of-View of Power and Campbell Robert Power (2001) argues the importance and impact of a time consuming observational approach and skill-based ethnographic techniques in the accuracy of a self-reported qualitative research study. (Power, 1989) The author mentioned that the modern research approach such as the use of computer technology in obtaining survey questionnaires and interviews increases the chance of developing a less accurate study due to the fact that first hand information which can be gathered through a keen personal observation on the survey participants’ facial reaction, sincerity in participating in the research study through the analysis on body language or gestures (Deacon, 2000) is being omitted in the data gathering process. (Power, 2001) In the case of Campbell, the author focuses on the use of a constructive chronological stories in relaying a complete compilation of important facts and information with regards to a member of a gang’s personal life such as in the case of Weeza’s life experiences; including several issues regarding the Sex Boys, and the Sex Girls among others. Campbell mentioned that considering the fact that some police officers attempt to gather only a ‘scattered information’ with regards to facts and figues related to community and neighbor gangs, the author concluded that there is a high possibility that the information that would come from police officers may not be a 100% accurate. (Campbell, 1984) It simply means that data gathering should be complete and precise in order to maintain the accuracy of data gathering for the purpose of a research study. Even though conducting a personal interview is time consuming, Power still consider this procedure to be very useful and one of the best approaches when it comes to conducting a research study on illegal drugs. Power (2001) highlighted the importance of being able to adopt a more ‘flexible qualitative research method’ in conducting an evidence-based research studies. He stated as an example that the use of inductive multi-method approach and observational approach is a better choice when it comes to studying social behavior. Campbell’s (1984) approach in the study of social behavior, particularly in the case of black and Puerto Rican women who lives in New York, was written based on a descriptive interview, idiographical, and non-judgemental approach and is purely based on facts. (Kornhauser & Hirschi, 1986) The author described the kind of life that Weeza has experienced since birth, the hardship that she has gone through in order to financially support her two kids, the men that comes in and out of her life, until such time that Popeye was murdered causing extreme despair on her life. Similar to the way Campbell has presented the case of Weeza, Power also uses a descriptive methor in exploring his personal experience the night he spent time with Eamon, Julie, and the boys. He clearly described the reason and how Eamon and Julie shared a syringe on their heroin consumption. Importance of Ethnography in the Research Study related to the Use of Illegal Drugs Ethnography plays an importance role in the study of illegal drugs. The use of this approach as part of the data gathering process requires a lot of skill and quick thinking. Normally, ethnographers are being challenged to effectively increase their target participants’ interest in the research study the researcher is assigned to conduct. (Broadhead, 1984) As part of arousing the curiousity of the target participants, the researcher has to be less informative when it comes to the research study process. According to Lofland & Lofland (1984), ethonographers should be careful in selecting the type of clothing as well as their personal grooming in order to avoid getting the target participants aloof with the researcher. It is also necessary for the ethnographers to be relax and open in terms of sharing their own thoughts to the target interviewee so as to win their trust when it comes to ensuring that the participants’ identity will remain confidential. (Broadhead, 2001) When dealing with drug users, it is possible that the researcher has to tell a lie in order to gather an accurate input for the research study. (Broadhead, 2001) In the case of Power (2001), he met Eamon and Julie quite a few times inside the drug clinic area inlcuding their residence place before he was able to win their trust and convinced them (Eamon and Julie) to participate in the research study by going through a personal interview with him. In the case of Campbell (1984), it has been evident how she uses a friendly and accomodating approach when it comes to conducting the interview with Weezca. The purpose of such approach is to unconsciously influence Weezca to unguardedly share her personal experience to the interviewer. Conclusion There are a lot of valid ways in conducting a research study on drug users and gangs. Both Power (2001) and Campbell (1984) agree that conducting a personal interview on their target participants is one of the best ways in gathering useful and accurate information for the research study. Personally, I strongly agree with Power’s opinion when he mentioned that a personal (one-on-one) communication with the target participants could result to unlimited useful information since ethnographers or researchers could unconsciously influence and motivate the target participants to speak up their thoughts and feelings when it comes to their personal experiences related to gangs and illegal drugs. *** End *** References: Broadhead, R. (1984). Human Rights and Human Subjects: Ethics and Strategies in Social Science Research. In Broadhead R.S. (Eds) Hustler in Drug-Related Aids Prevention: Ethnographers, Outreach Workers, Injection Drug Users. Sociological Inquiry , 54(2): 107 - 123. Broadhead, R. (2001). Hustlers in Drug-Related Aids Prevention: Ethnographers, Outreach Workers, Injection Drug Users. Addiction Research & Theory , 9(6):545 - 556. Campbell, A. (1984). The Girls in the Gang: A Report from New York City. New York: Basil Blackwell. pp. 106 - 175. Deacon, S. (2000). Creativity within Qualitative Research on Families: New Ideas for Old Methods. The Qualitative Report , 4(3 & 4). Faris, R. (1967). Chicago Sociology. in Power R. (Eds) Reflections on Participant Observation in Drugs Research. San Francisco: Chandler. Feldman, H. (1968). Ideological Supports to Becoming and Remaining a Heroin Addict. In Power R. (eds) Reflections on Participant Observation in Drug Research. Jounral of Health and Social Behavior , 9:131 - 139. Griffiths, P., Gossop, M., Powis, B., & Strang, J. (1993). Reaching Hidden Populations of Drug Users by Priveledged Access Interviews: Methodological and Practical Issues. Addiction , 88:1617 - 1626. Kornhauser, R., & Hirschi, T. (1986). The Girls in the Gang: A Report from New York City. By Anne Campbell. The American Journal of Sociology , 92(2):514 - 516. Lofland, J., & Lofland, L. (1984). Analyzing Social Settings. A Guide to Qualitative Observation and Analysis. In Broadhead R.S. (Eds) Hustlers in Drug-Related Aids PreventionL Ethnographers, Outreach Workers, Injection Drug Users. New York: Wadsworth. Power, R. (1989). Participant Observation and its Place in the Study of Illicit Drug Abuse. In Power R. (Eds) Reflections on Participant Observation in Drug Research. British Journal of Addiction , 84: 43 - 52. Power, R. (2001). Reflections on Participant Observation in Drug Research. Addiction Research & Theory , 9(4):325 - 337. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Pure Observational Approach

Designing an Observational Situation

Designing an observational Situation Observation of students at work in a classroom is an important part of dynamic assessment and increasingly useful for children with learning problems (Johnson et al.... A.... 2005).... The observation should entail setting clear and achievable targets to ensure the instruction and experience in the class achieve the target....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Observations of Children in the Preoperational Stage

he advantage of using the anecdotal record is that it allows for an opportunity to use the humanistic approach to provide for values to be placed on the nature of what occurs.... The Rogerian approach provides for looking at what occurs objectively so that it can be objectively evaluated.... Keeping this framework in mind, the observational techniques were used in non-invasive and inclusive methods.... he child that was chosen for this observational opportunity has been given the name 'Alice' for this discussion and to protect her identity....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Methods of research that warrant the use of qualitative research methods in Criminal Justice

Continuous knowledge development is critical for criminal justice/security management.... This is achieved through the application of different types of research and research methods to gather information which can be used to provide further insights into this field of study.... ... ... ... There are two dominant research methods applied in the study of criminal justice/security management which are quantitative and qualitative methods....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Six Research Methods, Advantages, and Disadvantages of the Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches

The paper "Six Research Methods, Advantages, and Disadvantages of the Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches" addresses the nuances of longitudinal and observational studies, interview and focus groups studies, questionnaires and Delphi technique, and various applications of these methods.... Longitudinal studies as well as observational studies are generally used in those places where a lot of time is taken to finally extract useful information....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Observational Method in Psychological Research

("Observational") Depending on the problem of the study and the whole idea of the research, an appropriate observational approach may be identified according to the strengths and weaknesses of each approach.... Its key feature is a standardised, planned, and systematic approach to objectively observe and record behaviour.... ("Introduction") Naturalistic observation approach is deemed as the most reliable method in studies that involve an observation of specific subjects....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Observational Report

Brown (2004) concurs with the stated and adds that it was hardly an optimal approach as, in more cases than not, the students in question do not need to be taken out of the general educations classroom.... The question of whether or not students assessed as requiring special education need to be transferred out of the general education classroom is the focal point of this observational report....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Ways in which Takei and Coates Approach Observation in Their Research: A Comparative Analysis

The "Ways in which Takei and Coates approach Observation in Their Research: A Comparative Analysis" paper initially and briefly looks into the meaning of observational research.... It identifies the basic difference between a qualitative versus a quantitative approach in the observation method.... Depending on the objective of the study, a certain approach is more appropriate than the other.... In addition, factors such as the nature or type of questions that would be administered, the sample size, skills and training of the researcher, and future prospects would determine the kind of approach necessary for particular research....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Epistemological Approach to Social Analysis

"Epistemological approach to Social Analysis" paper examines the meaning of epistemology, differences in epistemological positions to objectivism and constructions, theoretical perspective theoretical stance in social research, and methodological approaches to social research.... Walter (2010) notes that objectivism also holds that people can discern this objective reality if they approach it in the appropriate way.... ositivism is a quantitative, empirical approach in which supposition testing is utilized in discovering facts and relationships that can be generalized to a populace which entails logical empiricism, psychodynamic development, and behaviorism....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us